|

Bismillah-hirrah-ma-nirraheem.
In consonance with the glorious
tradition established by Allah’s Messengers, including the last and
the final Apostle Mohammad, this communication commences with the
blessings of Raheem, the nurturer of gradual changes and
Rehman, the nourisher of the spontaneous transformations occurring
simultaneously, throughout the entire cosmos.
[Salaaman]
[Wishing peace, prosperity and safety
to you.]
My good
friend, Malik told me about your website. It is both interesting and
even shocking to learn that the Muslims have gained enough courage to
criticize, Mohammad, the Qur’an, and other Islamic literature. In my
opinion, it is the only way to differentiate between reality and myth.
However, criticism must be conducted, utilizing Allah’s greatest gift,
the sense of reasoning and it must be constructive with the intention
of reaching the truth.
Some
people pass judgment on Mohammad and the Qur’an, without any just
cause. They seem to believe in the philosophy of condemnation for the
sake of condemnation, which does neither indicate right attitude or
correct approach. However, in most cases, it is not all their fault,
as they are basing their judgment upon the distorted translations of
the Qur’an and the worthless Islamic literature, fabricated three
centuries after the death of Mohammad, classified as Ahadith,
Sunnah, Traditions and Fiqah.
However, most of the ‘critics’ are Arabic illiterate and have no
knowledge of the last Book. They base their criticism on hearsay; what
they heard from their grandmas and some other unreliable sources. Not
a single one had a real critical approach to the subject or had done
any study of the Qur’an. This approach is both unscientific and
unjustified.
It is
my pleasure to come across your website, as it has provided me an
opportunity to respond to the objections [mostly frivolous] raised
against the Qur’an and the last Messenger of Allah. Before I embark
upon that perilous journey, I would like to introduce myself.
I am
Akhtar Sherazi and have recently published an over 600 page
publication, entitled, ‘The Qur’anic Concept of Nikah [wedlock]
vs. Religious Prostitution,’ which shall soon be available at all
Chapters outlets within North America.[However at present you can
place order on line to Chapters and Amazon . com] Therein, you shall
find detailed answers to the criticism that has been posted on your
website.
However, I don’t know how many of your contributors may get hold of
that book; with this in mind I have decided to answer all queries
received by you till date, in the same numerical order, you have
maintained. My tools are the Qur’an and Allah provided sense of
appreciation and understanding. I am doing this with the intention of
clearing up doubts created by the misinformation coming from your
contributors due to a clear lack of knowledge on their part about the
last Messenger of Allah and the last Book bestowed upon him. If I
could achieve any success in that effort, I shall consider myself to
be the luckiest man on earth.
The
abbreviations used below indicate the following:
C =
Criticism and A = Answer
Criticism No-1
bqayyum@hotmail.com
C-1:
So, it is not the religion, which makes one good or bad, although
religion preaches hatred and apartheid and imposing their concept of
truth on others. Thus I feel that all religions should be discarded
and some new religion (or call it code of living) should be drafted
for betterment of the humanity. I further believe that religion has
its roots in illiteracy.
A-1: Of
course all past and present religions, including the current sectarian
Islamic priesthood preach hatred, promote intolerance, endorse
self-righteousness at the expense of others, spread illiteracy and
sponsor religious confrontation. However, the Message of the Qur’an is
totally free of all such perverted ideas, pertaining to sect formation
and dividing Ummah into watertight compartments. The existing
political parties and Muslim sects are against the tenets of the
Qur’an, In fact, the Qur’an condemns sect formation and identifies it
as a serious crime against humanity.
The
Qur’an does not present any religion; it offers the Divine Social
Order, the best constitution ever produced, which was revealed to
Mohammad for solving all human problems. In the Qu’ranic terminology,
religion personifies an abominable social evil, which has nothing to
do with the rule of law encrypted in the last revelation of Allah.
This Charter of Rights and Obligations is comparable to the democratic
legislation, with one big difference; the people, who implement this
system, have no lust for power and hunger for wealth. They have
nothing to do with the modern day dishonest politicians, lying through
their teeth during the election campaigns and doing the opposite when
they get hold of the reins of power. Last, but not the least, the
wealth does not get accumulated in few hands, giving immense power to
individuals over the common people.
It
shall be advisable to discard all religions and implement the simple
and straightforward tenets of the Qur’an. It must be the same system
that was implemented by Mohammad in Medina and Mecca 1400 years ago
that changed the course of history.
C-2:
Irfan Khawaja
It
was my grandmother who gave me the bulk of my religious instruction.
She taught me the Quran, told me Quranic stories (my favorite was the
story of Nuh, given the connection with animals), and told me
frightening tales of kyamat, jahannum, and al akhira. She also filled
me head with powerful visions of
Paradise.
Several things bothered me about Islam. First, why was it necessary
for Muhammad to kill so many people in the course of his prophecy? Why
was conquest so central to Islamic history from its very beginning?
Why did women occupy so low a station? If Islam was meant to bring
blessedness "fi dunia w'al akhira" why was the Muslim world steeped in
wretchedness? And why was Muslim hagiography so pathetically
ill-equipped to deal with the arguments of Western Orientalism?
With
years' hindsight, I see the merit in secular versions of Muslim
rituals, and I practice them. I stop five times a day to reflect on my
life, or simply to stop. I think there is some value in fasting, as
there is in charity.
A-2:
With due respect to your grandmother, it is observed that she painted
a very dismal picture of the Islamic society established by the last
Messenger of Allah, because of her awfully poor knowledge about the
last Messenger and his lifetime work. Actually, she did not recount
the real truth about Islam, but narrated the Islamic folklore to you.
She must have been ignorant about the fact that the last Messenger of
Allah fought only defensive battles and his only wish was to establish
a peaceful society for the entire humankind. I want to point out here
that you are talking on the basis of hearsay. Have you ever tried to
fathom the truth that has been interwoven with the myth and legends?
The Islam portrayed by Muslim preachers has nothing to do with
Allah’s Al-Deen, presented by the Qur’an, which is currently the least
understood book in the entire world.
You did
a right thing by quitting five daily prayers, as this ritual is
un-Islamic and is not authorized by the Qur’an. The so-called Western
Orientalists are a bunch of misguided nincompoops, who base their
criticism of Islam on Ahadith, Sunnah, Fiqah,
Traditions and distorted Islamic History. All of them possess marginal
understanding of the Qur’an, as they follow the translations of the
so-called Muslim exponents, who did not undertake any independent
research of their own. They, in fact, copied the first immensely
flawed interpretation of the Qur’an, written by Ibne Kateer, a diehard
Iranian conspirator, who was deadly against Mohammad, the Arab.
In the
time of the last Messenger, women had equal rights, which were later
usurped by the Muslim caliphs, with the collusion of the priesthood.
The Ummah is passing through a phase of ignorance, which is worst than
the one that existed in the pre-Islamic era. The real Al-Deen
had been high jacked by Mullah mafia, supported by the rulers, over
the a millennium.
The
reason you are so confused is that you did not try to comprehend the
only Book [Qur’an] that matters. The rest is nothing but a pile of
junk.
To put
the issues in their proper perspective, I am trying to present the
real significance of the Qur'anic terms ‘Qyaamat,’ ‘Jahannum’
and ‘fi dunia w'al akhira:’
Qyaamat
This
word signifies the time of resultant outcome or consequence, either
good or bad, of an individual or collective [national] effort or
action. With the establishment of that definition, the Youm-ul-
Qyaama simply means the day or the time of beneficial or dreadful
results coming up, as a result of the kind of efforts made.
An
appropriate example shall bring home the point being made. If a
person starts heating water in a pan at the sea level, it shall start
boiling at 100 degrees Centigrade. Now that moment is the
Youm-ul-Qyama for the water, irrespective of the fact that the
heat is generated by wood, charcoal, gas or a spirit lamp. However,
the time required for this process depends on the operator, who can
bring about boiling very slowly or quickly by controlling the heat
source. Naturally, the Youm-ul-Qyaama of water is variable, as
it depends on the procedure adopted and followed by the person.
Similarly, Youm-ul-Qyaama of human life in conjunction with the
physical, chemical and biological laws of the universe are exclusively
in the hands of humankind. Good work by a society or even an
individual produces good effects on the social setup and it becomes
progressive in all spheres of human activity. On the contrary, bad
efforts end up in disaster.
However, Youm-ul-Qyaama does not, by any stretch of imagination
means the doomsday, the end of the world, or the day of the Last
Judgment. The Islamic priesthood, against the tenets of the Qur’an,
has promoted this thought just to scare the people for procuring hefty
donations, because they vehemently insist that such contribution shall
save them on the Day of Accountability.
Another
concrete example from the history shall further elucidate the
viewpoint developed for the Youm-ul-Qyaama. The creation of
Bangladesh, which opted for independence from India in 1947, got sick
and tired of the injustice leveled against it by the politicians of
West Pakistan for almost 35 years. Its Youm-ul-Qyaama finally
arrived in 1972, when it declared itself to be a separate sovereign
country, having nothing to do with the West Pakistan. This was
the day or time of Qyaamat for both wings of the country.
According to Bangladeshi people it was good, as they carved out an
independent state for themselves, whereas for West Pakistanis it was
just the opposite. In fact, it was Allah’s punishment for both sides
and both countries are still suffering its ill effects.
Fidunia w'al akhira
This
expression carries the connotation of both the present time and the
future. However, the latter can be classified in two categories,
anticipated [concerning coming generations] and outlying [that of the
hereafter]. Undoubtedly, the quality of life in those time periods
would be dependent upon their current activities. The nations enjoying
a peaceful, prosperous and secure present shall ensure better future
for their descendants and pleasant time for themselves, in the life
after life.
Jahannum
This
term reflects upon the mental and intellectual atrophy of an
individual or a nation that destroys its creative capabilities. It is
a kind of affliction that wipes out the artistic talent and innate
dexterity of the people, resulting in diminutive production capacity.
Conditions of confusion, depression and disorder spread around,
affecting the earning capability on the whole, creating a social
trauma or a veritable physical inferno for the individual and the
nation. The word Jahannum aptly describes such a situation,
wherein the regular nourishment of body and mind reduces to a bare
minimum. Conversely, the life wherein human personality develops to
its full potential and becomes highly creative and ingenious,
producing innumerable products for every person’s use, without any
kind of bondage or slavery is described by the word Jannah a
living paradise, as opposed to a burning hell described above.
With
regard to the question, ‘Why was it necessary for Mohammad to kill so
many people during the course of his prophecy?’ The answer is as
under:
According to the Quran, all Messengers of Allah, including Mohammad,
did not present prophecy of any kind. They were all equipped with one
constitution, in consonance with the realities of this world, for the
guidance of the entire humankind. Being an avid student of the Qur’an,
I could not find a single verse in the last revelation that commands
the indiscriminate killing of Jews, Christians or other people. The
concept of prophecy is un-Islamic and was in vogue in the Jewish and
Christian religious circles before the arrival of Mohammad, the last
Messenger of Allah. The adherent of Sunnah and writers of
Ahadith and Fiqah picked it again, around three centuries
after the passing away of Mohammad.
However, the Qur’an says in the verse 5; 32, ‘If a person is killed
unjustly, it is like killing the whole humanity. Conversely, if a
single life is saved, it is like saving the entire humankind.’
In the
face of such clear-cut commands of the Qur’an, Mohammad could never go
ahead and kill people indiscriminately, without any just cause. It is
just a stinking lie hurled against the impeccable character of
Mohammad.
It must
be kept in mind that all Messengers of Allah tried their level best to
avoid unnecessary bloodshed and for that very reason all of them,
including Mohammad, had to leave their places of birth. They did not
want to spill the blood of their relatives and friends.
However, what is your opinion about Americans, who killed 175, 000
innocent people in the twin cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki on August
6 and 9, 1945 consecutively. They are the biggest terrorists in the
history of humans. What are they doing in Afghanistan and Iraq? Do you
know they have killed more than 500,000 Muslims in both countries,
within the last year and a half? What are they doing in those
countries? Why don’t they get the hell out of there right now? They
have miserably failed to implant their kind of democracy before and
they are doomed to failure even now. Who needs their so-called
democratic system rotten down to the core, where the candidates lie
and cheat, together with stooping down to the character assassination
of each other, just to win measly four years in the White House?
The
Islamic Shariah, Ahadith and Fiqah, a bunch of
worthless crap has done grave injustice to the Muslim women and
humiliated them throughout the centuries. Pay attention to what Qur’an
says about them:
The Qur’anic verses 23:1 & 5, confirm
that only the social system, wherein both women and men guard their
chastity, shall be progressive, successful and ideal.
 
‘You the companions [both women and
men] of Mohammad, struggling hard for the establishment of a peaceful
social order; keep one thing in mind that your efforts shall become
fruitful only and you shall surely achieve success, prosperity, safety
and Allah’s blessings, if you guard your chastity and save yourself
from all kinds of sexual depravities!’
With the command delivered through the verse
33: 35, the Qur’an liberated women from century’s old sexual bondage
at the hands of men.
Every woman, like each man has her own distinct
personality and is no more an object just for carnal pleasure of
males. She can also achieve honor and dignity in her own right, by
guarding her chastity.

·
‘If men have the
potential to develop their own persona by harmonizing themselves with
the directives of Allah, then women also possess similar inherent
excellence.
·
If men can become
members of the movement, aiming to achieve world peace, through the
application of Allah’s eternal laws, then women also can participate
in that organization, just by becoming its members.
·
If men can streamline
their capabilities to work within the limits, set by Allah’s code of
ethics, women can accomplish the same.
·
If men can vindicate the
truth of their convictions, through their practical implementation in
life, women can perform the same feat.
·
If men can remain
steadfast on the path chosen by them, women can act likewise.
·
If men have
inexhaustible capacity to get more and more in harmony with the
Allah’s commandments, once they are set on that path, women also have
boundless energy to do so.
·
If men can sacrifice
baser thoughts for higher ideals, women have the potential to get at
par with them.
·
If men can control
themselves, without violating the limitations imposed upon them, women
can do better.
·
If men can keep their sexual urge within the prescribed
limits, so can women.
·
If men can understand
Allah’s rules and focus their activities accordingly, women can be
equally effective.
·
If both men and women
possess identical capacities and potentials, then the results they
achieve should be similar. Hence, both will enjoy equal protection and
security, and all other amenities that shall accrue because of their
good deeds.’
Therefore, according to the above
verse, women have their own self-respect, dignity, identical rights
and honor, but the Islamic priesthood with the connivance of the
respective hegemonies in most Muslim countries, has been denying women
their basic rights for centuries.
The remarks of the last century’s
great Muslim leader, Quaid-e-Azam, Mohammad Ali Jinnah, founder of
Pakistan, are worth mentioning, about the liberation of women, based
upon the Qur’anic ideology.
An excerpt from his speech, delivered
on March 10, 1944, at a meeting of Muslim League, held at the Muslim
University of Aligarh, runs as follows:
“Another very important matter, which
I wish to impress upon you, is that no nation can rise to the height
of glory unless your women are side by side with you. We are victims
of evil customs. It is a crime against humanity to shut up your women
within the four walls of the houses, as prisoners. I do not mean that
we should imitate the evils of Western life. However, let us try to
raise the status of our women according to our own Islamic ideals and
standards. There is no sanction anywhere for the deplorable conditions
in which our women have to live. You should take your woman along with
you as comrades in every sphere of life, avoiding the corrupt
practices of the Western society. You cannot expect a woman, who is
ignorant herself to bring up your children properly. Women have the
power to bring up children on right lines. Let us not throw away this
asset.”
[Speeches, statements and Message
of Quid-e-Azam, Vol. 3, P. 1853]
“The ‘weaker sex’ is more powerful
than both sword and pen,” was the view expressed by Mr. M. A. Jinnah,
while addressing the students of Jinnah Islamia College for women, in
Lahore, on March 25, 1940.
He said, “I have always maintained
that no nation can ever be worthy of its existence that cannot take
its women along with the men. No struggle can ever succeed without
women participating side by side with men. There are two powers in the
world; one is the sword and the other is the pen. There is a great
competition and rivalry between the two. There is a third power
stronger than both; that of the women.”
“It is women and women alone, who can
teach men how and when to wield the sword or pen, when the occasion
arises. You, young women, are more fortunate than your mothers are.
You are being emancipated. I do not mean that you should copy the
West. But I do mean that every man must be made to understand that
each woman is his equal and that woman is his friend and comrade and
they together can build up homes, families and nations.”
[Speeches, Statements and Message
of the Quid-e-Azam, Vol. 2, P. 1939-40]
The Qur’an commands both male and
female, to protect the pearl of chastity. It must be a permanent trait
of human personality, for it helps to build a strong character.
Regarding that, Mr. Jinnah declared
this message to his nation,
“Try your level best to learn the
sense of responsibility and duty. Build up your character; that is
more than all degrees. All degrees and no character is mere waste of
time. You should also develop the sense of honor, integrity and duty.
We are not, even a bit, inferior to any other nation. We have simply
neglected to develop these qualities, which we could. Believe me, the
day these qualities are fully developed, your home – Pakistan – is
yours.”
C-3:
So I created a mental schizophrenia where I ignored the real barbaric
and xenphobic nature of Islam with the reality I was experiencing. In
my heart I always felt that the inequality of women was wrong, that
non-Muslims were just as equal and human as Muslims, that science
provided much more reasonable explanations of the world than the myths
of Islam ever did. But I was too paralyzed by fear and by not wanting
to upset my family, so I never said anything.
I
had an extremely difficult crisis of the soul. I knew the extreme
contempt that Islam had for homosexuality, and I felt that I would
suffer the torments of hell for feeling the way I did. I tried
committing suicide in college, but was saved by a friend. That was the
turning point. I decided I was no longer going to be a slave to a
barbaric, fascist, sexist, homophobic, totalitarian, obscurantist,
cult-like, joyless, loveless, fear-mongering (should I add more
adjectives?) horrible horrible horrible ideology!
Today, free of Islam and religion, I
feel more liberated and powerful and in control of my life than I
could have ever imagined.
SH
shz99@hotmail.com
A-3: Your problem is that you are
confusing the current Mullah mafia as the manifestation of the real
Qur’anic society. Unfortunately, that is not the right thinking. The
current sectarian Islam has got nothing to do with the Qur’anic state
established by the last Messenger of Allah, in Medina and Mecca, 1400
years ago, which was destroyed by the power and money hungry caliphs
with the collusion of Muslim clergy.
In the beginning of the 21st
century, we are experiencing the Iranian version of Islam, which is
just an antithesis of the Qur’anic constitution. All kinds of rituals
that are celebrated by the Muslims, the world over, are condemned by
the last revelation. Darood-o-salaam, zikar, healing
powers of the Qur’anic ayas, ‘Mairaj Sharif’, Hajj
and many more has no Qur’anic authenticity. All such Biddats
appeared in 3rd and 4th centuries Higra,
along with Mullahs, Eunuchs, Sufis and Mausoleums. All of these
shameless activities were non-existent in the time of the last
Messenger and even in that of his stalwart companions.
However, the Qur’an categorizes gay
culture as unnatural, because it does not fall into the category of
Zwaj or heterosexual couple. Gay and lesbian
relationships are considered to be an affliction that must be cured
through medicinal or psychological therapies. Heterosexual couples
produce children, propagating the human race, whereas homosexual only
waste the precious baby making juices. The Qur’an wants to correct
this situation and bring back the marginalized gays and lesbians into
the main stream of the society.
Death penalty for an apostate is a
cruel and barbaric fabrication of the Islamic priesthood, which the
Qur’an does not support at all. Nevertheless, being born in a Muslim
family does not make some one a Muslim. Every child, while coming of
age and even in the later part of life, must learn to differentiation
between Al-Deen and the contemporary religions and has to make
its own choice, utilizing Allah given sense of reasoning and
understanding. If a person does all that and still sticks to the
Islamic way of life, such an individual turns out to be a real Muslim.
Jews can be Jews by birth and so can
be Christians, but it is different with Muslims. They have to learn
the Qur’an and understand the verses without any help from synthesized
Sunnah, fabricated Ahadith, and mixed-up Fiqah.
Since the Muslims have given up the right of choice, they are in the
hellhole. Jews and Christians have become secular, because their
revelations have become extinct, millennia ago. They have stopped
bothering about them. That is why a Christian or a Jew is so by
birth.
The real Muslims described above
stopped existing, since the Iranian influence infiltrated the Abbasid
courts and their purported exponents changed the meanings of the
Qur’anic words, terms and expressions, with the full support of the
caliphs. They tried to change the text of the Last revelation, but
could not do so for the following two reasons:
·
Firstly, Arabic is a
language of roots like Hebrew and Aramaic. The latter was the lingo of
the Anjeel, which was given to Jesus. But the original Book got
lost a long time ago and the Bible, which has nothing to do with the
real revelation, is now accepted as the word of God. The Jewish books
existing in this day and age are corrupted beyond recognition, but
since the creation of Israel, a strong effort is underway for the
revival of Hebrew, as a medium of communication. However, the Qur’an
still exists in its original form, pertaining to its index, text and
syntax.
·
Secondly, in that period
there were hundreds of thousands of Arabs, who had memorized the
entire Qur’an, which made changing the script an insurmountable task,
in their presence.
The scientific discoveries in all
fields of knowledge have no clash with the Qur’an. In fact, they are
supporting the realities expressed by the Qur’an 1400 years ago.
However, the Church had a number of them, a couple of which are worth
mentioning here.
Firstly, the credibility of Bible was
severely damaged by the confrontation the Christian priesthood had
with the geologists about the existence of the planet Earth, as part
of the Solar System. The latter were putting forth a time span of 4.5
billion years, on the basis of their in-depth studies, whereas the
former were adamantly stuck to the figure of 4,500 years on the basis
on some odd calculations done, incorporating ‘certain evidence’
provided by the Bible. Eventually, the Papal hierarchy gave in to the
scientific truth, which caused a great deal of humiliation and
embarrassment to the institution and adversely affected the legacy of
the Bible, as the book based on truth.
Secondly,
Galileo claimed that Earth revolves around the Sun, but the
Church maintained the dogma that it’s the other way round. He was
first put under house arrest and then made to live in solitary
environment. During this period he suffered physical infirmity, which
later on resulted in blindness. In 1992, the Pope realized the
Church’s mistake, after a lap of 350 years and came up with the
following comments:
“That while
17th-century theologians based their decision on the knowledge
available to them at the time, they had wronged Galileo by not
recognizing the difference between a question relating to scientific
investigation and one falling into the realm of doctrine of the
faith.”
Unfortunately, the true Islam is
nowhere to be found, within the current, 57 independent Muslim
majority states. In view of that situation, it is an excellent
decision on your part to liberate yourself from the authoritarian,
joyless, and dreadful cultist ideology of the theocratic Islam, but
not the Qur’an, as it respects your basic rights and freedom of
choice. You are opting to be a homosexual and of course you shall face
terrible consequences of this unnatural practice. The people, who defy
nature, are slapped into oblivion. Allah has created this fluid energy
for procreation and not for wasting, but if you want to live that way,
it is your choice.
The unprejudiced study of the Qur’an,
with an open mind, shall alleviate despondency from your life. Allah’s
guidance shall eradicate your mental aberration, free you from the
state of trepidation and cure your schizophrenia.
In the verse 4:137, the Qur’an states,
‘the people who quit practicing the Qur’anic code in their lives,
shall neither find protection from Allah’s Laws, nor shall they ever
find the right path to live happily.’
 
‘Those, who first accepted Islam
[started struggling for the establishment of a peaceful society based
on the Qur'anic constitution], then went back and joined the opposite
camp [non-Muslims], once again turned around to become a part of the
Muslim Ummah, but left one time more and then grew stubborn in
their denial of the truth; such type of people shall neither be
protected from the Laws of Allah, nor they shall ever find the right
path. They shall plunge deeper into ignorance and ignominy.’
Therefore, according to the above
verse of the Qur’an, you are free to accept or reject the Qur'anic
commandments. Additionally, there is no capital punishment for any
Muslim, who wants to rescind his allegiance to Allah and the Qur’an.
Every one has full liberty either to belong to the Muslim community or
go the other way. There is complete freedom of choice for every Muslim
to become Hindu, Christian, Jew or an agnostic; whatever suits
someone’s palate of belief.
Death penalty for an apostate is the
fabrication of the Islamic priesthood and Iranian Imams. They invented
the term ‘apostate’ and injected it into the Islamic Shariah,
with a view to keep a firm hold on their respective sects and dissuade
their followers from wandering away or changing sides, due to the
hanging sword of decapitation over their heads. This concept is,
however, alien to the Qur’an and is nothing more than an erroneous
belief.
C-4:
I cannot understand the marriage between the prophet of Islam and
Ayesha. In my view, mullahs or the ulemas twist this incident or avoid
talking about it. From my boyhood, I heard that the prophet was 50
years and she was 9 years but later in an esteemed newspaper
Sajid
Ashraf
N.B. My
email is the following
prudent_56@yahoo.com (people who do or do not share my view may
contact)
A-4: You did arrive at the right
conclusion that the Iranian, both Shi’ah and Sunni Imams
of the 3rd and 4th century Higra, maliciously
created the myth of Mohammad and Ayesha’s Nikah, despite
the fact that Allah has imposed the following restrictions, with
respect to the selection of the spouses, in order to facilitate a
happy and harmonious married life:
They should have comparable views
about the life in general, must have similar physical and mental
attributes and be of the same age. [57:37]
·
They must have come of
age, reached physical and mental maturity to make their own decisions
and must possess sufficient means of subsistence. [4:6]
·
They must be of sound
mind, have sufficient strength to brave the rigors of life and must be
full of vitality to enjoy the bliss of married life. [6:152]
It is imperative here to check up with
the Qur’an about Mohammad’s social behavior and the kinds of
commandments given to him by his Nourisher.
·
The verse 33:52
pronounces openly, ‘Mohammad your are forbidden to marry any other
woman, besides the one’s, who are already in your Nikah!’
·
As per Surah Al-Threem,
Mohammad had two wives at the time of his appointment to the exalted
position of the Messenger of Allah. Despite the clear-cut command of
the last revelation about his matrimonial limitations, how could
Mohammad do, whatever he had been reported to be accomplishing by the
compulsive Iranian liars, 300 years after his death? It does not make
any sense, as the Messengers of Allah strictly adhere to the
revelations they receive. Mohammad could never deviate from the
explicit instructions passed on to him pertaining to his marital life
and he could never indulge in the nefarious activities you have
mentioned on the basis of the purported ‘Islamic literature.’ It is
nothing but sordid kind of mudslinging on his impeccable character.
·
The verse 47:4, declares
a complete ban on all kinds of slavery and Mohammad personally
promulgated this proclamation of Allah, then how could he go against
it and commit the despicable acts that you blame him for? This kind of
character assassination is the height of spitefulness, which his
Iranian enemies leveled against him, because they are not a part of
the Muslim Ummah, but are the worshippers of Mazdak.
·
The verses 33:50-52
clearly show that at the time of receiving the high office of Allah’s
Messenger, he had only two wives. He was also forbidden from taking
new wives or divorcing his existing ones; then how could he go out and
marry women left and right? This evidence destroys the malicious slur
you have concocted against him.
·
In the verse 33:4-5,
Allah forbids the adoption of other people’s sons or daughters.
Mohammad could never have gone against that clear-cut directive and
declared Zaid as his son. This is an unadulterated falsehood. It means
the story built upon this incident did not materialize ever, as he
never adopted any son. Zainab, the name of Zaid’s alleged wife does
not appear anywhere in the Qur’an. In addition, according to the verse
33:55, Mohammad was the figurative father of his nation and could not
marry any woman as per the direct command of Allah to maintain his
exalted image within his nation. Therefore, the marriage of Zainab
with him is nothing but a blatant lie of the worst kind. To find the
truth about this fictitious event in detail, you should get hold of my
book entitled, ‘The Qur'anic concept of Nikah vs. Religious
prostitution.’
The Quran has an excellent
continuation of discussions on all aspects of human life, without any
abrupt changes of topics. The screwed up translations might give that
impression. Not a single existing translation of the Qur’an has done
justice to the last revelation of Allah. The simple and
straightforward message of the Qur’an has been corrupted, though the
text remains intact. In fact, the legendary repetitive style of Arabic
vernacular has been utilized to make the subject matter easily
comprehensible. In order to reach the real connotation of each word,
term and expression, it is essential to follow the built-in procedure
laid down in the Qur’an. All a person has to do is to check every
word, used with respect to various contexts in different verses, to
grasp its real significance applicable to each and every aya.
Only this way, it is possible to completely understand the over and
undertones of each phrase, expression presented in each Surah
[chapter].
Consistent with the verses 23:5,
24:30, 70:29, 24:3, all Messengers of Allah, including Mohammad, were
righteous, honorable and immaculate individuals, who guarded their
unblemished characters in the fortress of Nikah. In view of
this irrefutable evidence, it is ridiculous and preposterous to say
that Mohammad along with all other Messengers of Allah were debauched
and decadent lechers.
In the presence of the above mentioned
basic tenets of the Qur'an for Nikah between a man and a woman,
how could Mohammad possibly wed a girl, who is said to be 6, 9 or 15
years old, when he personally, was close to 50? This tantamount to
open defiance of the revelation that he received, which he would never
have even dared to think about. The piles of Ahadith and the
accounts of Sunnah, pertaining to this subject, are nothing but
a pack of lies, which the Iranian Imams, his most vindictive
antagonists, fabricated to ridicule Mohammad the Arab and invalidate
the constitution he implemented.
In addition, Ayesha and Khadijah,
Zainab, and Fatma [non existing daughter of Mohammad] are non-Arabic
names and there is no truth in the myth that Mohammad ever married
non-Arab women. The fact of the matter is, these names have Iranian
origin and the Ahadith manufacturers of these stories forgot
this aspect, while instituting these names in their falsehoods.
C-5:
I spent most of my free time attending religious gatherings in
Lahore, Pakistan. I spent
about 6 years with Maulana Moudidi. About 8 years with Allama Ghulam
Ahmad Pervez. I studied nearly everything about Islam on which I could
lay my hands. By the time I was 40, my concept about religion had
changed absolutely. The offensive and intollarant stance of Islam had
created repulsive attitude about religion. I stopped believing in
anything like god, messanger, life hereafter and so on. Then I read
some articles from the humanist forum. Presently I am ashamed to be
born to a Muslim family. But I don't know what to do because the
society in which I live executes those who leave Islam. Can someone
guide me what I could do.
Qayyum
bqayyum@hotmail.com
A-5: I
can very well visualize your situation, because long time ago, I was
in the same boat, you find yourself in now. But, then I worked hard to
understand the Qur’an and currently, I am a changed person altogether
and enjoy the tranquility bestowed upon me by the last revelation of
Allah. You can reach me through my ID
quranicresearchinc@hotmail.com anytime you want and I shall
happily try to answer all of your questions. Please do not hesitate to
contact me, as I am of the view, it is a blessing to understand the
real Muslim, through one’s own efforts. I shall be delighted to help
you out of this predicament, which I personally experienced a long
time ago.
C-6:
Do you believe that Muslims have the right to kill Buddhist, Hindus,
red Indians, etc? Do you believe that Christians and Jews deserve the
un-equal treatment they have received and still receive in Muslim
countries, the Dhimmitude status? Do you believe that a husband have
the right to hit a "disobediant" wife? Do you believe that a father
should have the right to kill a "disobediant" daughter; the so called
honour-killings? This is what the Koran stands for, Adibah, and if you
are wearing a headscarf you are announcing to the world that you
despise the non-Muslim democracies, the Western way of life, tolerance
equality and understanding. In short, that you despise everything I
believe in, and values that I hold sacred. (If you do not believe that
Muslims despise Western society, just read the comment posted below
your own.) Adibah, I can hear you protest and say that this is not
what the Koran says. To my experience, many Muslim women do not know
much about the Koran. Start reading it, especially Sura 4. Women. You
can get a lot of information on this web site and here are plenty of
useful links. And includ scraf.
Adiba!
Best wishes, Johanna from Sweden
e-mail:vildhassel@hotmail.comhttp://www.hti.umich.edu/cgi/k/koran/koran-idx?type=simple&
q1=unbeliever&size=First+100
A-6:
You hurled the following insinuations against the Qur’an.
·
The Qur’an commands
Muslim to kill Buddhist, Hindus and the red Indians.
·
The Qur’an directs a
husband to hit a disobedient wife and a father to kill a disobedient
daughter, on the plea of honor killing.
·
The Qur’an instructs
the Muslims to treat Christian and Jews as not their equals.
·
The Qur’an orders
Muslim women to wear headscarves.
Can you
quote any verse, as evidence, in support of your allegations against
the Qur’an, enumerated above? I am especially interested to know
verses through which the Qur’an issues such specific commandments
against the non-Muslims.
However, in defiance to your unwarranted and unsubstantiated
accusations, the Qur’an states in the verse 5; 32, ‘if one kills a
person without a just cause, it shall tantamount to the killing of the
whole humanity. Conversely, ‘if one saves the life of a single person,
it shall be like saving the entire humankind.’
Your
unconfirmed allegation that the Qur’an orders Muslims to hate
Christian, Jews and Hindus is, completely baseless.
The
Qur’an, contradicting your point of view, states in the verse 17:70,
‘certainly, every individual [regardless of race, religion, color and
nationality] on this planet is equally honored in the sight of Allah.
Unquestionably, the noblest among you from Allah’s standpoint is the
one, who adheres to Allah’s commandments for the establishment of a
peaceful and prosperous society in this world.’ [49:13]
The
Qur’an does not direct women to wear headscarves or [Hijab]. It
does not authorize fathers and husbands to kill their daughters or hit
their wives, under the pretext of honor killing or improving their
behavior. The disgusting and uncouth Islamic priesthood has concocted
this disgusting and repugnant directive.
You
have charged that the Muslims are not treating Christians and Jews as
their equals. What is your opinion about the mass graves in Bosnia and
Kosovo, which were filled in with the bodies of ruthlessly, massacred
unarmed Muslim men, women and children by their Christian neighbors?
What do you think about indiscriminate killing of innocent Muslim men,
women and children in Iraq and Afghanistan by the American Christians?
How would you categorize the action taken by the American Christians
against the 175,000 Buddhist civilians of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, who
were blasted away by two atomic bombs? Had they ever been punished for
their crimes against humanity? What is your opinion about the illegal
occupation of the lands of Palestine and Kashmir by the Zionists and
the Hindus and the continued state terrorism against the non-
combatants in both areas? Do you think the wholesale killing of
Kashmiri Muslims and the atrocious raping of their women, by the
thousands are really good deeds? On top of that, do you have any
concept, how inhumanly blameless Muslim men are treated in the
dreadful prisons maintained by Christians, Jews and Hindus?
Your
suggestion for Adibah to read Surah 4, ‘The Women’ is a
wonderful idea. In this chapter, Allah has provided detailed
instructions pertaining to both wedlock and divorce. In addition,
women have been accorded, for the first time in human history, their
real place in the society with dignity and honor. It has also been
stressed upon men that in some respect they are superior to them.
In
fact, this particular section of the Qur’an provides pertinent
guidance to the sexually over liberated Western society, where 40 % of
the kids never know, who were the sperm donors or their biological
fathers, because their mothers can not keep track of their promiscuous
relationships. Additionally, in here, the Qur’an deals at length with
the treatment of Muslim women both at home and in the society and can
be of immense interest to the modern Western culture, wherein the
female is attached great importance just as a sex symbol and a
commodity that sells like an excellent commodity. Here, a remedy is
also presented for keeping the sex predators in check, who boast about
having sexual intercourse with more than 6,000 women. This Surah
has an excellent guideline for the girls, who get pregnant before
celebrating their 15th birthday and provides help for those
men and women of the Western society that suffer from excessive sexual
libido or over drive.
Last,
but not the least, the Surah of the Qur’an under reference
provides an excellent solution for rectifying the sexual holocaust
destroying the Western culture, irreparably. These verses have the key
for setting right the social trauma prevalent, especially, in the form
of over-growing numbers of single parents, in the so-called advanced
countries. Here, the most beneficial way is indicated for creating a
well-knit and coherent family unit that constitutes the basic
component for building up a robust social setup, which ensures the
physical and mental health of the coming generations. These pole
bearers can only vouch for the global peace and prosperity. Surely,
throughout this Surah, you shall not find a single verse,
commanding the women to wear headscarves or Ahjab [plural of
Hijab].
Your
comments pertaining to the Dhimmitude statues are baseless and
demonstrate your complete ignorance of the Qur'an and its Message. In
fact, the last revelation impresses upon the Muslims to preserve the
historical monuments for the coming generations and directs the Muslim
men and women to become archeologist and explore the historical
realities of the bygone nations, in order to determine the causes of
their last vanishing act. The evidence of this liberal attitude is
demonstrated by the fact that Muslim rulers did not damage any of the
obelisks, temples, pyramids or any other artifact of antiquity, during
the last thirteen centuries of their rule in Egypt.
The
Taliban were not Muslims according to the definition of the Qur’an and
whatever they did in Afghanistan does not befit a Muslim regime.
Growing beards, that is mandatory as per the Sikh religion or wearing
headscarves that the Christian nuns practice does not make any one a
real good Muslim. They were the worst example of Mullah Mafia that is
severely condemned by the Qur’an. The American exhibited similar
attitude in Iraq, as they did nothing to secure the priceless
artifacts, collected over centuries, in the Iraqi museums. In
addition, the American forces damaged the Hanging Gardens of Babylon,
by demolishing the walls and using the bricks for building their
fortification in and around that area. This is called the height of
irresponsibility and shear apathy.
C-7:
My mother was a religious fanatic and she instilled Islam in my heart
through fear later on this fear matured into religious fanaticism. I
am a highly sexed man and Islam offered me legalization of lust
through inspiring me of four marriages. I could not understand the
marriage of Ayesha to the prophet. In spite being born in a Sunni
family I could not understand Umars cruelty termed as services for
Islam. Islam advocates Equality but why was the prophet given
priviledges. Muhammed has shown me a lot. If a person is
psychologically smart he can sell any idea whether worshipping dog
too.
Sinclaire
sakhnaton@hotmail.com
A-7:
Fanaticism is the basic tenet of all religions and is prevalent around
the globe, including the current Islamic priesthood that is spread
like a giant octopus in all 57 Muslim majority countries. Your mother
was not a fanatic, but a misguided Muslim, who never tried to
understand the Qur’an, on her own. She was simply following the way
shown to her by the Mullah Mafia. In my opinion she was a great woman,
who brought you up to the best of her ability, giving you pertinent
understanding of yourself and how to utilize your Allah given gift of
intellect.
It is
good that you are a very virile man and not a nerd, but the common
concept of four marriages permissible for a Muslim male, under
ordinary circumstances, is blown way out of proportion. The Qur’an
basically stresses upon monogamy, whereas polygamy is only allowed for
exceptional conditions. As they say, ‘extraordinary situations require
extraordinary measures,’ it is the stopgap arrangement for the
duration of an emergent state of affairs. A typical example could be
presented of the post-war Germany, where 7 million women could not
find husbands, as the demographics had been severely disturbed,
because of the gargantuan loss of men during the Second World War. If
the Qur’anic Law of Polygamy had been invoked and every man had taken
up to 4 wives, the problem due to the excessive number of women had
been solved. A similar situation arose for the nascent Islamic
government in Medina, due to a large influx of single and divorced
women, who had accepted Islam and had nowhere else to go, except the
capital of the newly formed Islamic state. However, with the return of
normalcy, the order for polygamy was withdrawn.
You are
under the wrong impression that polygamy is for the sexual
satisfaction of men like you, suffering from the condition known as,
Satyriasis. What would be the solution, if one of your wives turns out
to be a Nymphomaniac and does not get sexual satisfaction
from you? Is she allowed to seek 4 husbands in consonance of your
theory of 4 wives? Think about it!
To find
the correct answer pertaining to the myth of Ayesha and Mohammad’s
marriage, please look under C-4.
C-8:
I have been a Muslim since I was born in
Pakistan. I got master degree in
computer science and am a famous figure in computers community. . I
might need some financial help for a short time and then I will be
back to my life. This Pakistan is a SHIT place to be in and islam is
to blame for all the hypocrisy here. Although, if I tell others that I
am leaving Islam, I will be KILLED. Hence, I am sharing my heart-deep
thoughts with you. In these circumstances, I intend to commit suicide
by going to Jihad in Afghanistan or Kashmir. See, how easy and
rewarding it is to commit suicide i Islam.
E-Mail
me at masoomzindagi@hotmail.com .
Call me
"ALI". Bye
A-8:
The Qur’an does not recognize you as a Muslim, even if you were born
in a Muslim family. It is a misconception that a person becomes a
Muslim just by birth. According to Allah’s last revelation, you only
deem fit to be called a Muslim, if you study the Book utilizing your
intellect and sense of reasoning, gifts of Allah, when you reach the
age of maturity and then accept Al-Deen as your way of life, of
your own volition. The coercive circumstances in which you are
surviving, do not give you any right to be called a Muslim. You are
suffering from self-deception in that regard.
The
terms good or bad are relevant and interchangeable. You curse your
homeland Pakistan for very wrong reasons, because it is not the land,
but the people, who matter. A draconian system is in place within your
country, but the people, including you, neither have the will nor a
plan to uproot it. Tell me! Who is at fault?
However, the Qur’an condemns suicide, as it is a sign of defeated
mentality. The people, who lose hope and find no way out of their
predicament, undertake such an abominable act. It might interest you
to know that the Japanese, Denmark and Swedan people are having the
highest suicide rate in the world. There, juvenile girls become
suicidal, if they could not achieve 95% marks in a test and got only
90% instead. You get life only once; live it out instead of putting an
end to it. To end one’s own life is the most cowardly act possible.
C-9:
Now, I have decided not to practice Islam anymore, and if I was to
relate how many negative experiences I have had with Muslims since I
converted, I could write a whole book, so I am still faithful, but
dont particularly believe in the "religious" aspect of Islam. To me,
it is a bunch of irrational BS that becomes only acceptable when
people are submitted to extensive brainwash. Anyways, I still do my
prayers but I dont think Islam is "the perfect religion" as many
Muslims say.
feel
free to contact me at
lukeache@yahoo.com
A-9:
For a starter, the modern day Islam has got nothing to do with the
real Islam that was practiced in the time of Mohammad, because the
rituals you are practicing now were alien to that way of life.
Unfortunately, you are not the follower of the Qur’an, but that of the
‘mumbo jumbo’ created by the Islamic priesthood. Then how can you make
Islam or rather the Qur’an responsible for all irrationality going
around? You say you are still praying, but the last Messenger of Allah
never did so, as there is no directive in the last revelation of Allah
to that effect. The alleged Shi’ah and Sunni Iranian Imams created
this ritual almost three centuries, after the demise of the last
Messenger.
Islam
is not a religion, but Al-Deen or a way of life, or even
better, a constitution. All contemporary faiths are riddled with
rituals and customs, including the alleged ‘MODERN’ Islam shaped up by
the Mullah Mafia. A pertinent example shall clear up the difference
between the two. The American constitution is a way of life; it
entails all essential ingredients for running the country on
democratic lines, but there are no ceremonial procedures, like 5 daily
prayers and a host of others to be followed. The Qur’an enjoys exactly
an identical status; it is Allah’s constitution for the benefit of the
entire humankind, without any rituals and customs, which came into
existence centuries after the death of Mohammad. He, however, put the
given manifesto into practice and exhibited its immense benefits to
the other nations, to follow suit, if they wanted to accrue the same
advantages, ensured by this system.
In the
real sense of the word, you are not practicing Islam at all, so
leaving or keeping it becomes immaterial. In fact, it shall not make
any difference in the real sense and shall turn into an exercise in
futility.
C-10:
I am from pakistan , a
25 years old male .. up to the age of 24 I was a very religious
person. But that was not my decision to be religious but you do not
have any other option in a country like pakistan, our environment is
very rigid and extereme when it comes to religion, Islam discoureges
to question and think too much but only follow and believe. I was
lucky to get a good friend who showed me the actual face of islam. The
point important for me is that islam only proves itself by terrifying
the people and it is the fear through which it is rulling on the
people fear of death , fear of hell etc.
Comments will be welcomed either positve or negative
freethinker101@hotmail.com
A-10:
It is the religion called ‘Islam’ that creates an umbrella of fear all
around you, inclusive of Allah, the Saints, the death, the grave, the
Day of Judgment and many more hyped and nonsensical ‘mumbo jumbos.’
The Islamic priesthood, with the intention of keeping people under
their thumb for keeping their lucrative business running, perpetuates
this sort of dogma. You will be surprised to know that religion is the
most extensive and the highest paying business of the world, whether
Christians, Muslims, Hindus, Jews or Sikh carry it on. The Priests,
Mullahs, Pundits, Rabbis and Grunthies mint tones of money on daily
basis, without investing anything from their own pockets. On top of
that, there is no audit of the daily collections and it is all
tax-free. This all is accomplished by creating the dread of religious
persecution and chastisement at the hands of the priesthood, if their
following ever dares to go astray. There is another reality worth
noting here; the technological advancement and the industrial
revolution took a foothold in Europe, when Pope of Rome and his
cohorts were thrown out of the window. The worst religious persecution
occurred in that part of the world, under the tyranny of ruling
priests. The life of Michael Angelo presents the epitome of the most
horrible subjugation.
The
Qur’an, on the other hand states, ‘when you will implement the tenets
of Allah and establish the government based on the Qur’anic
constitution, you shall be free of all kinds of qualms and worries,
including that of outside aggression. Peace and tranquility shall
prevail in your stable society.
C-11:
There is a misconception in the minds of every Muslim that just
reading the Arabic text of Quran is an act of great reward from God. .
As there are many factions in Islam, I will try to mention those
rituals which are followed by all. Daily: Early in the morning (before
dawn) there echoes adhan (call for Morning Prayer) with prefixing and
suffixing poems praising Muhammad . There is Eid (three days of
happiness) just after the completion of the month of Ramadan. On day
one, a special prayer is offered in the mosques after the sun rises.
c. Eid-ul-Adha: It is celebrated on the 10th to 12th of Islamic month
Zilhaj A special prayer is offered in the mosques after the sun rises.
And after offering the prayer, animals (sheep, got, cow, ox, camel)
are slaughtered in the name of Sunnah of prophet Ibrahim. Moreover, on
these days, Muslims from all over the world gather in
Mecca (a holy city for Muslims in
Saudi Arabia) to perform Hajj which is called one of the five pillars
of Islam. d. Moharram: This is the holiest month of the Shiite faction
of Islam. During this month the Shiites mourn the death of grandsons,
granddaughters etc. of Muhammad who were killed by Hasid, the then
Governor of Koofa. The Shiites gather in their respective Imambargahs
(mosques of Shiites) and then go in the form of procession to the main
Imambargah of the city. All the way they beat their chests as a
gesture of mourning. Some emotional hit their backs with knife-like
blades tied with chains. It takes many hours for the procession to
reach the main place. It is important to mention that when there is a
procession on the road, the road is blocked for all type of traffic,
in any case. The real Islam disgraces women, permits men to beat their
wives, that imposes discrimatary laws on the religious minorities,
that wants to rule the world by converting all the non-Muslims into
Muslims, that calls for Jihad and killing the non-muslims until Islam
becomes the only religion of the World. According to the Islam saying
of prayers (five times a day) is the vital difference between Muslims
and non Muslims. Moreover, it keeps the Muslims away from doing bad
acts. I do not see any other religion whose teachings are in contrast
to the teachings of Islam. Obviously good is good in all the religions
and vice versa. Further, Muslims believe that Islam is the only true
religion. I see no quality distinguishing them from the rest of the
world. Generally, I do not see their character in conformity with the
accepted principles of right and wrong.
Contact me: Zaabrifd@yahoo.com
A-11:
You did aptly paint the decadent picture of the current Islam, which
has been reduced to a collection of worthless rites and rituals,
including 5 daily prayers. In fact, the word Salah does not
connote the customary bowing down to Allah, which switches on indolent
and languid attitude in the human personality. This misrepresentation
of the Qur’anic term Salah put a stop to the active progressive
drive within the society, setting in degeneration of the worst kind.
Would you believe that within the last one hundred years, Muslims have
not turned up with a single invention?
In
fact, the expression Salah signifies Allah’s divine social
order, a perfect and complete constitution for the entire humankind,
revealed to Mohammad through the mighty medium of galactic Gabriel
energy. But what is happening in the 21st century; 70 to
80% of the Muslims, on the worldwide basis, just read the Arabic text
of the Qur’an, without understanding a single word. This is the only
nation on the face of the earth that is subjecting its revealed book
to such a contemptuous treatment. This is the height of international
Islamic apathy towards Allah’s invigorating set of laws. Arabic
illiteracy has damaged the cause of Islam extensively for the last one
thousand years.
Look at
the Shi’ahs, who yearly mourn a fictional tragedy, on a
grandiose scale, especially in South Asia, Iran and southern enclave
of Iraq, relating to the alleged killing of Mohammad’s grandson
Hussain through his daughter Fatima and son-in-law Ali, along with
some of his close relatives. This charade, created by the Iranian
mischief mongers, is enacted during the first ten days of the first
month of the Islamic calendar, on a yearly basis, with the grand
finale on the last day. This entire episode has nothing to do with the
constitution bestowed upon the humankind by the Qur’an, but it forms
the basis of the Shi’ah religion.
However, as it is said, mendacity does not have solid ground under its
feet, so this story concocted by the Iranian conspirators, is
unraveling, as a result of the modern research. Authentic documents,
found is Spain, prove beyond shadow of a doubt, that Hussain, the
governor of Koofa [a city in modern Iraq], was murdered in the bedroom
of his palace by the son of Hurmazan, a diehard Zoroastrian, who had
pledged to destroy the Muslim power, by killing the charismatic
leadership of the movement.
The
latest research shows that Ali remained governor of Koofa, till his
death. After him, his eldest son Hassan resumed that responsibility,
but he suffered from a rare medical condition identified as Satyriasis
[libido overdrive] and died soon, due to the progressive physical
debility, resulting from excessive sexual intercourse. At that moment,
Hussain took over the reins of power in Koofa and held the office for
quite sometime, but Hurmazan’s son also decapitated him, in his own
bedroom, with a single blow of a machete like sword.
The
fake Iranian Muslims, the enemies of Mohammad, the Quran and Allah
came up with all kinds of fictitious stories, about the slaughter of
his kith and kin at Karbala, Iraq. A vast majority of Shiite
illiterates firmly believe in the account narrated by the hired
Zakars [flamboyant and firebrand raconteurs] about the imaginative
atrocities inflicted by male heirs of Mohammad’s closest companions,
upon Hussain and his family.
It is,
however, interesting to note that the alleged Imam Hussian was an Arab
and strangely enough not even in a single Arab country, the legendary
express of grief about him goes on with the same grief, as it happens
in the non-Arab countries like Iran, India and Pakistan. Nonetheless,
most of the Arab nations do not take any notice of this event at all.
Naturally, it means the sworn Iranian enemies of the Arabs came up
with the concocted account of Hussain’s ‘martyrdom’ by the bank of
Euphrates [Arabic Faraat] and drummed it up so much that it became
their mainstream religion. I am of the opinion that with their extreme
leftist attitude, they created intensely warped interpretation of the
Qur’an and blocked all avenues leading to the freedom bestowing code,
enshrined in the last revelation. Instead of enjoying ample rewards
for promoting real Islam, they invented ridiculous rites and rituals,
which do not carry even an iota of common sense. They killed Hussain
themselves [blamed others for the act] and then turned his
commemoration into a yearly event of sacrament or self-punishment.
What a dastardly façade they arrange every year, which has no
relevance to the tenets of the Qur’an. As a student of the Qur’an, I
firmly believe that Shi’ah, Sunni and numerous other
sects collectively constitute the main obstacle in the establishment
of a government based upon the constitution presented by the Book of
Allah.
The
five daily prayers are fabrication of the Islamic priesthood.
According to the Qur’an, Mohammad never prayed like that in his entire
life Moreover, the Qur’an does not direct people to practice such
imperceptive and time wasting rituals [like faraz, sunnat,
naffal, viter, traveeh, and tahajud
prayers or indulging in darood-o-slam].
The
five daily prayers, azzan, praising Mohammad, celebration of
Eid , Eid-ul-Adha, [slaughtering the lamb in the name of Sunnah
of prophet Abraham] are against the principles enunciated by the
Qur’an and are nothing, but rituals synthesized by the Islamic
priesthoo d.
C-12- Several things bothered me about
Islam. First, why was it necessary for Muhammad to kill so many people
in the course of his prophecy
Leaving one’s religion seems suicidal Each of all of the thousands
mosques became the ideological powerhouses of the mass-killers and
mass-rapers. All those 1.2 billion Muslims are wrong. They are trapped
in a wishful utopia; a fancy romantic dream-palace called Islam. They
take their life-force from the cruel instructions of the Koran and
Prophet’s life. And the peaceful Muslims’ obsession in the name of
faith (Imaan) actively strengthens the killer Islamists. Muslims are
taught to blindly believe every word of Koran and save the letters and
words of the Koran/Hadis even at the cost of human lives of other
sects, women and non-Muslims.
“Even if I am given the sun in one hand and the moon in the other, I
won’t stop preaching”. And also I saw the same Prophet involved in
slaughtering non-Muslim tribes, selling slaves of all ages, men and
women, kids, youths and olds. I saw him driving his followers to kill
others on the basis of faith, sleeping with his slave-girls, marrying
kid, his lust (vividly described in our books) for his own
daughter-in-law (wife of his adopted son), grabbing the properties of
non-Muslims and taking their most beautiful women, having sex within
days of the slaughter of the women’s’ husbands and fathers. Also I saw
his extreme cruelty to establish Islam, cutting hands/feet off and
passing red-hot iron on the I faced the truth of the mess of the
Koran/Hadith. The Koran does not contain a single humane teaching,
which was not there before Islam. Mankind will not loose a single
moral if Islam is not there tomorrow. Saying good words is easy, all
those Koran’s good words can be said by any conscientious person, even
an atheist. The Koran has a big portion dedicated to clear violence
towards non-Muslims and Jews. There is no question of so-called
“misinterpretation”. You cannot misinterpret “Killing” as “Kissing” or
vice versa. Muslims did not misinterpret wife-beating, marrying 4
wives, divorcing at will without showing any reason or excuse to
anybody, sleeping with unlimited slave-girls, get involved in
slave-business, “cleaning” the Arab Peninsula of Pagans, women’s half
inheritance, women’s less credible witness in the court, laws crushing
non-Muslims. Omar did not misinterpret anything but obeyed one of
Prophet’s one of last three instructions when he “cleared” Arabian
Desert of non-Muslims. Don’t we still see some of those torturous
claws of Islamic “values” in some “Laws” of Nigeria, Pakistan
Afghanistan………………….. ?
eyes of enemies before killing them,
his cursing of non-Muslims,
The
Koran has no chronology. Some 86000 elements are sorted, divided and
blended there in a horrible messy way. For any single topic one has to
jump around the whole Koran only to find one sentence here and another
sentence there. Extremely important rules and laws are kept vague and
dangerously left open to interpretation and application by people of
any depth and moral. There is no conformation of the final instruction
in case of different instruction on the same issue. The topic suddenly
changes from North Pole to South Pole in the next line. Natural
calamities are used as threats. Koran’s effort to trap people by
scaring them is evident. An effort to hook people by lowly “bait” like
sex with beautiful women in heaven is evident. These attitudes do not
suit the grace and honour of a divine religion.
In
Islam human beings are used as coins to buy God’s pleasure, as in case
of freeing slaves for “cleaning” from sins. Rich people are preferred
as being able to free slaves and to perform Hajj. Human beings are
declared as enemy of God. Burning of meteorites in the sky is
described as arrows to Satan. “Jinns” are said to climb to the sky to
listen to the gossip of the angels. Prophet Moses is described as
running on the crowded road completely naked. Monkeys were stoned for
adultery. After it “sets”, the sun is described to prostrate to God to
seek permission to rise next day. Newborns are said to cry because
Satan pinches on its body. Yawning is said to of God’s disliking.
Every aspect of Islamic attraction of the heaven is attributable only
to the desert. Not a thing in the Koran is beyond the precinct of
Arabia. All its Prophets and characters, problems and solutions, hopes
and aspirations, incidences and accidents revolve only around the
ancient Middle East. Not a single Prophet or character of Islam and
Koran is beyond the Middle East; like all the gods of Hindus are from
India.
www.ladyliterature-films.com/TheSleeplessNight.htm
TELL
ME WHY THE NATIONAL FLAGS OF MANY MUSLIM COUNTRIES HAVE SWORD IN THEM?
A sword is not for shelving beard, it is only for killing. WITH THE
HYPOCRICY AND CUNNING GAME OF SWEET ADVICE AND CRUEL LAWS, THE KORAN
CONCLUSIVELY HAS EMERGED AS THE MOST DANGEROUS BOOK TO MANKIND.
The
ritual of “Quorbani”, the “Sacrifice” did not do any good to Muslims
for a thousand years. It referred to Prophet Abraham who left his wife
and child in the open desert to die. Islam makes Muslims to criticise
other social evils, but blind to see its own cruelties. To be honest,
I always felt ashamed whenever I read my books of Sharia Laws, both
from Sunni’s and Shia’s. Islam definitely cleared up some primitive
social systems of the ignorant desert people of that time. But its
claim to bring “light” to the whole world is an insult to previous
philosophers and scientists of all the time in all the pl My
'apostasy' against Islam came about through a sustained critical
analysis of the fundam Born into a muslim family from Morocco and
raised in England It slowly dawned on me that the Qu'ran was not the
infallible, immutable word of God but a fascist slur on humanity,a
human document with little relevance to the modern condition as well
as the realisation of the countless contradictions, historical
inconsistencies and errors and some of the most intolerant verses ever
written.
. I hate Muhammad, I hate the koran, I
hate mecca, Ihate everything about it! How can help the world free
itself the death grip of this psychopath religion How can a man of
more than 50 years old have sexual feelings for a girl of only 6!
After he gave me a dissatisfactory answer i just went quiet and walked
away. I was out the door and i looked back, He looked at me and he put
his head down... i think he knew i wasn't goingI cant comprehend the
fact that a man of that age can fantasize about a 6 year old, and then
have sex with her while she was still playing with her dolls! And why
is it that a woman is lower than a man? is my mother lower than me?
why is it that a muslim can have 4 wives? can a woman not have 4
husbands then? and why did mohammed have more than 4 wives? doesn't he
believe in practice what you preach! Also how can i believe a man with
such low moral character? how can i believe in a man who does t
hings which i myself find
They should DUMP this evil satanic
cult immediately, and do with the koran as is done with all other
piles of useless TRASH! - commit it to the FLAMES! Any way, thank you
for your time, Thanks
AH
Please take a moment to view the website for my book:
www.ladyliterature-films.com/TheSleeplessNight.htm
MED
KHAN
A12- I am quoting below the most
repugnant and detestable segment of your remarks about Allah, Mohammad
and the Qur’an called Islam in its totality, for asking you a simple
question:
‘Leaving one’s religion seems suicidal
each of all of the thousands mosques became the ideological
powerhouses of the mass-killers and mass-rappers. All those 1.2
billion Muslims are wrong. They are trapped in a wishful utopia; a
fancy romantic dream-palace called Islam. They take their life force
from the cruel instructions of the Koran and Prophet’s life. And the
peaceful Muslims’ obsession in the name of faith (Imaan) actively
strengthens the killer Islamists. Muslims are taught to blindly
believe every word of Koran and save the letters and words of the
Koran/Hadis even at the cost of human lives of other sects, women and
non-Muslims.’
Do you understand the Qur’an, the last
revelation? If you say YES, then it means you are like millions of
other people, who have no concept, what this Book is all about,
because they suffer from mental aberration, being under the influence
of fabricated Ahadith, synthetic Sunnah, distorted
Fiqah, baseless Islamic Traditions and imprecise Islamic History.
However, if you say NO, then I shall request you to first understand
the Word of Allah, before making such vitriolic remarks. In both
instances, you are neither doing justice to the subject matter nor the
Messenger.
The first and the foremost problem of
the Arabic illiterate Muslim Ummah is that basic demarcation between
the Word of Allah and the filth created by the Iranian Shi’ah
and Sunni Imams is not established. The parts of common verbal
exchanges of Mohammad, reported, rather invented or self-composed by
the malicious, nasty and wicked religious priesthood [conspirators],
three/four centuries after the death of the last Messenger, are
revered by the ordinary Muslims, equivalent to the verses of the
Qur’an. Undoubtedly, that is the root cause of all problems. They must
understand that the Qur’an is the Word of Allah, the creator of the
universe and beyond, whereas writers of Ahadith, Sunnah
and other garbage were vicious people originating from Iran. They had
a score to settle with Mohammad the Arab, who overran their
magnificent Empire with his ragtag volunteer force, when they killed
his emissaries, without just cause.
I would be really obliged to you, if
you would come up with a single verse of the Qur’an in support of your
malevolent commentary about Allah, His last Messenger and the final
revelation!
Your venomous outburst is completely
based on the TRASH synthesized by the pseudo-Muslims Iranian Imams, in
the form of Ahadith, Sunnah, Fiqah and Islamic history. One can
guide the people along the right path, who are endowed with Allah
given gift of intelligence, but one can’t do much about those, who are
both deaf, dumb and blind or are incapable of utilizing their innate
mental capabilities. Cumulatively, they constitute a herd of sheep.
Your slanderous and insulting remarks
regarding the last Messenger of Allah that during his time, he was
sadistically involved in slaughtering non-Muslim tribes, selling
slaves of all kinds, including men, women and children, is nothing but
a blatant lie conjured up by the writers of Ahadith, Fiqah
and Traditions.
The blasphemy churned out against
Mohammad that ‘he used to sleep around with his slave-girls, was in
the habit of marrying kids or was a pedophile, loved to lust after
[vividly described in the alleged Islamic literature] his own
daughter-in-law [wife of his adopted son], enjoyed grabbing the
non-Muslims properties and abducting their most beautiful women for
his sexual enjoyment, within days of slaughtering their husbands or
fathers’, is nothing but baseless filth written by the notorious
authors of the ‘body of literature’ mentioned above.
It is imperative here to check up with
the Qur’an about Mohammad’s social behavior and the kinds of
commandments given to him by his Nourisher.
·
The verse 33:52
pronounces openly, ‘Mohammad your are forbidden to marry any other
woman, besides the one’s, who are already in your Nikah!’
·
As per Surah Al-Threem,
Mohammad had two wives at the time of his appointment to the exalted
position of the Messenger of Allah. Despite the clear-cut command of
the last revelation about his matrimonial limitations, how could
Mohammad do, whatever he had been reported to be accomplishing by the
compulsive Iranian liars, 300 years after his death? It does not make
any sense, as the Messengers of Allah strictly adhere to the
revelations they receive. Mohammad could never deviate from the
explicit instructions passed on to him pertaining to his marital life
and he could never indulge in the nefarious activities you have
mentioned on the basis of the purported ‘Islamic literature.’ It is
nothing but sordid kind of mudslinging on his impeccable character.
·
The verse 47:4, declares
a complete ban on all kinds of slavery and Mohammad personally
promulgated this proclamation of Allah, then how could he go against
it and commit the despicable acts that you blame him for? This kind of
character assassination is the height of spitefulness, which his
Iranian enemies leveled against him, because they are not a part of
the Muslim Ummah, but are the worshippers of Mazdak.
·
The verses 33:50-52
clearly show that at the time of receiving the high office of Allah’s
Messenger, he had only two wives. He was also forbidden from taking
new wives or divorcing his existing ones; then how could he go out and
marry women left and right? This evidence destroys the malicious slur
you have concocted against him.
·
In the verse 33:4-5,
Allah forbids the adoption of other people’s sons or daughters.
Mohammad could never have gone against that clear-cut directive and
declared Zaid as his son. This is an unadulterated falsehood. It means
the story built upon this incident did not materialize ever, as he
never adopted any son. Zainab, the name of Zaid’s alleged wife does
not appear anywhere in the Qur’an. In addition, according to the verse
33:55, Mohammad was the figurative father of his nation and could not
marry any woman as per the direct command of Allah to maintain his
exalted image within his nation. Therefore, the marriage of Zainab
with him is nothing but a blatant lie of the worst kind. To find the
truth about this fictitious event in detail, you should get hold of my
book entitled, ‘The Qur'anic concept of Nikah vs. Religious
prostitution.’
The Quran has an excellent
continuation of discussions on all aspects of human life, without any
abrupt changes of topics. The screwed up translations might give that
impression. Not a single existing translation of the Qur’an has done
justice to the last revelation of Allah. The simple and
straightforward message of the Qur’an has been corrupted, though the
text remains intact. In fact, the legendary repetitive style of Arabic
vernacular has been utilized to make the subject matter easily
comprehensible. In order to reach the real connotation of each word,
term and expression, it is essential to follow the built-in procedure
laid down in the Qur’an. All a person has to do is to check every
word, used with respect to various contexts in different verses, to
grasp its real significance applicable to each and every aya.
Only this way, it is possible to completely understand the over and
undertones of each phrase, expression presented in each Surah
[chapter].
Consistent with the verses 23:5,
24:30, 70:29, 24:3, all Messengers of Allah, including Mohammad, were
righteous, honorable and immaculate individuals, who guarded their
unblemished characters in the fortress of Nikah. In view of
this irrefutable evidence, it is ridiculous and preposterous to say
that Mohammad along with all other Messengers of Allah were debauched
and decadent lechers.
Releasing servants from bondage or performing the redundant ritual of
Hajj, does not absolve the crimes of Muslims rulers and religious
leaders. The devious Muslims clergy has created this ridiculous
misconception. The verse 47:4 forbids all kinds of slavery forthwith
and uprooted this social curse that was prevalent in the pre-Islamic
era. The Muslim priesthood borrowed this concept from the Christian
kings, queens and their cohorts, despite the clear injunctions of the
Qur’an against this derogatory and insulting human practice. On the
contrary, the Qur’an declares every human being to be equally
honorable in the sight of Allah and is only responsible or accountable
for its own deeds [53: 39].
The
current concepts of Jinns and Satan along with the degrading stories
of Moses running naked through the crowd and the stoning of a monkey
to death for committing the felony of adultery, originate with the
‘junk literature’ comprising of the fabricated Ahadith,
synthetic Sunnah, despicable Traditions and distorted Islamic History.
You
have raised an objection regarding Allah’s program of appointing all
Messengers to the Middle Eastern region. It sounds to be a valid
point, but shows complete deficiency of the Qur'anic literacy. In the
verses 4:164, 40:78, 34:34, 7:101, 10:47, 13:7, 16:36, the Qur’an
unequivocally announces to the whole wide world that Allah raised
Messengers within every nation, on this planet.
It says
‘We have mentioned some of them in the Qur’an, whereas many others
have been left out.’
Since
the last Messenger came from the Middle East, Allah presented life
sketches of the most important previous apostles, to show Mohammad the
hardships they faced and the ways they adopted for completing their
assignments successfully. If the last Messenger had appeared in China,
then Allah would have introduced his predecessors from that part of
the world to provide him the adequate knowledge of the region and its
people for properly preparing himself to get on with his assignment.
In that case, the Arabs might have asked the same question you did,
about all Messengers appearing over there. Additionally, the Arabs
were familiar with the previous apostles over millennia in their area
and did easily co-relate Mohammad with them.
Your
hostility towards the inclusion of the sword in the Saudi Arabian flag
is way out of proportion. It is just a symbolic representation of
power, as there are 50 stars in the American flag, showing to the
world that these states are united to face every challenge to their
unity and sovereignty. However, the Saudi flag was created almost half
century ago, when the House of Saud established its dynasty in the
Arabian Peninsula, which the Qur’an condemns in most powerful terms.
The blade has no Islamic significance and so should not give you any
qualms. However, if you look up the Coat of arms of various European
and American countries, you shall find a huge collection of weapons
and beasts of prey, beyond your wildest dreams.
Your
remarks, ‘that the Qur'an conclusively has emerged as the most
dangerous book to humankind,’ are not only obnoxious and derogatory,
but show your ignorance about the last revelation. Coming up with that
kind of sweeping statements, without making any effort on your part to
understand the language of the Book, exhibits your mean and nasty
nature. How dare you pass such derogatory comments about a document
that is beyond your comprehension! You are not at all qualified to say
anything of that sort. Better watch out your wagging and drooling
tongue!
The
ritual of Qurbani is not the ‘Sunnah of Abraham;’ it is another
sadistic creation of the Iranian priesthood. Allah does not require
any sacrificial lamb or a human teenager to be slaughtered in his
name. The Qur’an does not support any of the concocted stories
appearing for the first time during the 3rd and the 4th
century Higra. Abraham, the most respectable Messenger of Allah, did
not leave his wife, with a day old child in the desert. Sick Iranian
minds weaved up such baseless cobwebs of myth from Bible literature
and fable, in the name of Islam. The whole concoction is just a wash
out. [To fathom the truth of the real event, please look up my book
mentioned above.] My personal research, encompassing a period of 30
years, has proven to me beyond any doubt that the Qur’an is free of
all possible omissions and commissions; similar is the opinion of
Japanese researchers, who came out with a unanimous verdict that this
book is free of all possible human errors.
I have already answered the criticism
in the previous pages that the Qur’an does not sustain the concept of
prophetic prophecies. The Greek Vestal virgins used to practice that
‘hocus pocus’ out of the island of Lesbos, close to the mainland.
However, centuries later, this ridiculous tradition was adopted by the
Jews, Christians and the Islamic priesthood.
You must always remember that Mohammad
fought 75 defensive battles that were imposed upon him by his
adversaries. As a general rule, Allah’s Messengers try their level
best to avoid unnecessary bloodshed. For that very reason, each one of
them migrated from his birth place to a safe haven for practical
implementation of the constitution given to him and establish a
government accordingly, ensuring peace, prosperity and security for
the people. How could any Messenger of Allah go for indiscriminate
killing in such an environment?
The practical example of Mohammad’s
life was that he entered Mecca, the home of his worst adversaries, at
the head of a 10,000 strong battle-hardened force, equipped to the
teeth with most modern weapons available, but not a single drop of
blood hit the ground. He did not go after the people for personal
vendetta, who made his life miserable in that city earlier, but went
right away for the establishment of the same kind of government that
was working in Medina.
You have a right to hate the Qur’an,
Mohammad, Mecca and every other entity associated with him, but before
doing so, you must produce evidence from the Qur’an that Mohammad
really married a six years old girl. In the absence of tangible
material corroboration, your detestation is simply unwarranted and
totally biased. There is no provision in the Qur’an for having more
than one wife under normal set of circumstances, which means monogamy
is asserted by the last revelation for normal times. Even under
extraordinary conditions, there are about eight or nine conditions
that must be fulfilled before getting involved with the business of
polygamy.
[For more details, please consult my
book mentioned above, especially the chapter entitled Nikah [wedlock]
However, let me quote, what Allah says
about Mohammad, the Qur’an and Mecca:
·
‘Mohammed, you have the
most composed, balanced and decent individuality on the face of this
beautiful planet.’ [68:4]
·
‘Certainly, the Quran is
a book that clearly explains Allah’s immutable laws and is a source of
blessing and nourishment for those, who want to establish a peaceful
society in this world.’[7:52]
·
Ka’bah provides an
International Center for peace and a safe haven for the weak and poor
nations. Its main objective is to let the human race establish itself
on its own, without any shackles impeding its progress. [5:97]. The
ignoble sentiment of hatred for any one does not solve any problem,
but in fact destroys the person being its victim.
Before rejecting or accepting any
concept, the Quran suggests humans to use their Allah given gift of
wisdom and intellect for reaching the right decision and the most
precise action of the Ummah at this time would be to put the
despicable ‘literature’ created in the name of Mohammad by his most
awful Iranian enemies, the nasty and wicked Shi’ah and Sunni
Imams.
Lastly,
I would suggest you to please study my book, for the clarification
of your doubts you have in your mind.
C-13:
How many days did it take to create Heavens and Earth ?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Quran-7:54: Your gurdian-Lord is Allah who created the heavens and
earth in Six Days Quran-10:3: Verily your Lord is Allah, who created
the heavens and earth in Six Days Quran- 11:7: He it is Who created
the heavens and earth in Six Days Quran-25:29: He Who created the
heavens and earth and all that is between, in Six Days
The
above verses clearly state that God created the heaven and Allah
created the heaven and the Earth in 6 days. But the verses below
stated-
Quran-41:9 : Is it that ye deny Him who created the earth in Two Days
? Quran- 41:10: He set on the (earth) Mountains standing firm high
above it, and bestowed blessing on the earth, and measured therein all
things to give them nourishment in due proportion, in FOUR DAYS…
Quran-41:12: So He completed them (heavens) as seven firmaments in Two
days and …
Now
do the math: 2(for earth) + 4(for nourishment) + 2 (for heavens) = 8
days; and not 6 days.
A-13:
Firstly, I would like to clarify the meaning of the word Rabbakum.
The word Rabakum
signifies the Sustainer, the Cherisher and the Nourisher of the whole
universe and beyond; surely, there is no comparison between Him and
the big horde of ‘Lords’ created by the British Royalty, who carry out
all sorts of odd jobs for their masters.
Secondly, the word ‘Ayyam’ not
only signifies a 24 hour day on earth, but carries much wider meanings
in various verses of the Qur’an, like an epoch, an era, some specified
time, a particular stage or phase of an ongoing process, an age, or a
dimension denoted as Time, on cosmic scale.
In view
of the above clarifications, the essence of the verse 7: 54, would be
as follows:
‘Your
Sustainer, Nourisher or Cherisher has created heavens and Earth in six
stages, or six cosmological phases.’
Therein, the word ‘Ayyam’ does denote an ordinary earth day
comprised of 24 hours.
Again,
in the verse 41:9, the Qur’an pronounces,
‘O
Mohammad! Question them [your antagonists], isn’t it ridiculous to
compare and oppose this productive program with the human legislations
[Like democracy, socialism, capitalism and others]. This constitution
is from that powerful and mighty Allah, Who created the planet Earth,
through an evolutionary process, in two astronomical periods.
The
verse 41:11further elucidates the cosmic connotation of the verse
41:9, that We did not create your earth [living planet] only, but also
shaped the whole cosmos within those two periods. The verse 41:9 is
the extrapolation of the verse 41:11, with the supplemental
superimposition of all heavenly bodies.
The
most appropriate translation would be as follows.
‘We
evolved innumerable [not only seven] worlds or We completed the cosmic
designing and creation in two distinct ‘stages’ [from the primordial
raw material, hydrogen; 41:10] and imparted physical, chemical and
biological laws to each one for the best utilization with respect to
its functioning and control. We have adorned the skies with shining
stars [esthetic aspect of the creation] to present a magnificent
spectacle, especially at night, to the human eye, instead of leaving
there a horrifying deep void. They are secured in their orbits [by the
‘G’ force] and the entire universe is perfectly designed with respect
to its immense expanse, through the application of Our ubiquitous and
immutable laws.’
Tabulation, according to the Qur’anic math, six phases, segments or
stages emerge; two time frames for the evolution of earth and the rest
of the cosmos and four independent periods for the development of life
on earth, in its present form and inestimable other habitable planets.
The total works out to be: 2+4=6. Is it not simple enough to
comprehend?
In
order to facilitate the easy grasping of the meanings and
understanding of the text, the original author of the Qur’an [Allah],
adopted the familiar and comprehensive repetitive style in vogue at
that time. Even in the modern times, the best way of getting an idea
across is to explain it with appropriate examples.
Its
creator, keeping in view the general comprehension level its readers,
has presented the text of the Qur’an in a very popular and easily
understandable format. Naturally, this Book is meant for the guidance
of its common recipients and not the so-called exponents, who have
been incorporating their own ideas for the explanation of verses,
especially among the vast Arabic illiterate populace.
Allah
has touched upon the subject of creating cosmos in many verses, but
the most expressive, regarding the subject matter, are 7:54,
10:3,11:7, 25:59, 32:4, 50:38 and 57. These verses bear witness to the
fact that this gargantuan task was completed in six stages. The Qur’an
has repeatedly stressed upon the six stages of creation and in the
verses enumerated above, this subject has been specifically
discussed seven times in varying but exquisite, linguistic
expressions, making it very easy for every Arabic literate person to
comprehend. It would be childish to add up six stages mentioned in the
seven verses, to come up with a figure of 42, as it would be totally
erroneous from the vernacular, as well as, simple mathematical
calculation.
Moreover, the modern mathematics is not an exact science. Have you
heard about the most popular concept of the modern math, the Theory of
Probability? What does it mean? Think about it! The Qur’an has
provided the basic tenets for the people to apply and solve their
day-to-day problems. It is not a treatise on mathematical theories and
practice.
Q-14:
Similar mistakes you can see in the verse: Quran-4:11,
4:12, and 4: 176 in inheritance law.
In these verses one can see the total property after adding all
distributed parties adds up more than the available property, i.e.,
totals become more than 1 which are: 1.125 and 1.25. How come ? A
gross mathematical errors, is not it ?
A
-14: To begin with you must
improve upon your elementary knowledge of Fractions. General Fractions
usually don’t add up to unity or one, except in few exceptional cases.
Here
are a few examples for your consideration:
1.
1/2 + 1/3 + 1/4 = 13/12
2.
1/3 + 1/5 + 1/6 = 21/30 or 7/10
3.
1/3 +1/6 + 1/9 = 11/18
Thousands of such examples can be presented, showing that common
Fractions don’t add up to unity or one. This is an erroneous concept
to begin with, for which you are blaming the Qur’an. [Shame on you]
Please brush up your primary level math. The fractions that add up to
unity are as under:
1.
1/2 +1/2 = 2/2 or 1
2.
1/3 + 1/3 + 1/3 = 3/3 or 1
3.
¼ + ¼ + ¼ + ¼ = 4/4 or 1
Here
also, the interpretation of the given verses is not only implicitly
flawed, but way off the mark. Keeping in view, the rule of thumb
prescribed by the Qur’an for the division of inheritance among the
successors, the following aspects must be kept in mind:
In the
Islamic society set up in Medina, the Qur’an decided that the share of
a male heir would be twice as compared to that of a female. This rule
did not drop down just out of the blue and neither was Allah’s
intention of favoring men over women. Specific ground realties,
infused by the Word of Allah in that social setup, formed the basis of
this decision. These are mentioned below to elucidate the position a
woman did command as compared to a man, especially, pertaining to the
division of the parental inheritance:
·
At the time of marriage,
a female, surely, has superiority over the male, in the sense that the
husband has to present Nahlah [in the form of a gift, or a
piece of property, or cash, voluntarily and in accordance with his
financial position] to his wife, before the consummation of marriage.
·
After marriage, the wife
becomes equal partner with her husband in owning all mobile and
immobile assets. In view of this fact, she enjoys a better monetary
situation, as compared to her brother.
In view
of the above facts, a woman in the Islamic setup gets amply benefited
through her marriage, as compared to her brother. In order to
compensate him monetarily, his share in the inheritance has been
fixed at twice of his sister.
The
application of this simple rule leaves no confusion in the division of
property left by any person to its successors. A few examples shall
further elucidate this point.
Example
No. 1:
Suppose
a clear sum of $3,000.00, after taking care of the debts of the estate
and the shares of other relatives, remains to be divided between a
brother and his sister. According to the principle laid down by the
Qur’an, the brother takes twice the sum of his sister. So he gets
$2,000.00 compared to her $1,000.00.
Example
No 2:
Here,
one son and 10 daughters survive the deceased and the total amount
left to be disbursed among them is $12,000.00, after taking care of
other expenses.
As the
share of each daughter is equivalent to half that of the son, then
their 10 shares, in fact, correspond to 5 of their brother. Using
simple mathematics, the shares reduce to 6, five belonging to the
daughters and one to the son, making 5 + 1 = 6.
Now
each share is worth $2,000.00, as the total number of shares [6]
divides the total amount [$12,000.00]. Thus, the son gets $2,000.00,
whereas the ten daughters get $1,000.00 each, out of the remainder,
amounting to $10,000.00.
Example
No 3:
If the
sum of $ 7,000.00 is to be divided between one son and twelve
daughters, the same procedure should be adopted. The son has one share
whereas 12 daughters have 6 shares equivalent to their brother. Thus,
the total shares are 6 + 1= 7. In this way, each share is worth
$1,000.00. The son gets his share of $1,000.00 whereas the 12
daughters get $500.00 each, out of the remaining $6,000.00.
In view
of the above-cited examples, the distribution of inheritance does not
create any hassle at all. The procedure provided for is very simple
and straightforward, without any ambiguity. It is the Islamic priest
hood and, especially, the alleged Christian scholars of the Qur’an,
who create unnecessary problems through their convoluted explanations.
Moreover, the Qur’an presents clear-cut principles to be adopted for
solving practical problems and is not a treatise on mathematical
aberrations.
Here,
it seems appropriate to mention that the Islamic priesthood does not
recognize the right of grandchildren from the legacy of their
grandparents, though the Qur’an commands otherwise.
Q-15:
Allah’s Days Equal to 1000 Years or 50,000 Years ?
Quran-22:47: A day in the sight of the Lord is like a thousand years
of your reckoning. Quran-32:5: To Him, on a Day, the space whereof
will be a thousands years of your rekoning.
A-13:
The correct exposition of above verse is as under:
‘O
Mohammad! Instead of putting their mind sincerely to this constructive
program, they challenge you to wreak upon them the promised punishment
that you warn them about. Mohammad, go ahead and inform them that
Allah never fails to deliver upon His promise! They shall face the
consequences of their deeds at the appointed time. It is not in their
interest to hasten this process up through their ridiculous acts of
mockery and ridicule. It is definitely going to happen at the
appropriate time, according to His Law of Retribution.’
‘In
strict compliance with Our evolutionary process, every nation has to
reap, what it sows. The good or bad effects emerge and materialize in
the due course or Youm, as a consequence of the activities
undertaken. Allah’s Youm or His unit of time is equivalent to
thousands of years on your home planet, the Earth.’
In
fact, the term Youm incorporated by Allah, in this verse,
carries only a symbolic importance. The intention is not to establish
any equivalence between innumerable time zones existing throughout the
cosmos, but to bring home to the inhabitants of the entire universe,
that Allah’s planning, pertaining to the completion of certain
evolutionary steps, takes much longer, in comparison to the time scale
of the planet Earth. The world history is a witness to the fact that
the rise or fall of nations does not happen overnight, but it takes
hundred or even thousands of earthly years to finalize. That extended
period is what Allah intends to define as Youm.
In the
verse 32:5, the term Amr stands out conspicuously and is the
key to the understanding of its real significance. It
therefore, requires additional focus, before getting on with the
exposition of the said verse. The word Amr has a myriad of
meanings, encompassing an order, a command, authority, power,
dominion, a sign, a mark, a token and even the stones, which the
Bedouin used to drop on their way, while passing through a stretch of
unfamiliar desert for indicating the way back, on the return trip. The
term Amr was Allah’s first order of the Youm, right
before the creation of the cosmos. The region, where Allah’s physical,
chemical and biological laws take shape is known as Alam-ul-Amr.
What goes on in there is beyond the perception and conception of the
earthlings?
There
is another expression worth consideration, which is pronounced as
Alam-ul-Khalq. This signifies a place where ingredients or
constituents are mixed continuously to streamline the production of
varying life forms. Conversely, it means an extremely productive
location, where Allah’s divine planning remains in full swing and
dynamism is the order of the day. In fact, the entire cosmos is
Allah’s playground, where unimaginable events are taking place within
every nanosecond.
To have
a better understanding of the above concept, let us take the example
of water. This constitutes the basic ingredient for the propagation of
life. According to the modern scientific thinking, life can only take
root only on those planets, where water exists and the environment is
temperate enough to stay in a liquid form. According to the
anthropologists, the first mono cell originated in hot and humid areas
of the globe. Besides knowing the physical and chemical properties of
water, we also know its structure; two Hydrogen atoms are attached to
one Oxygen atom, in the form of coordinate bonds to create a single
water molecule. The question is; who infused such inherent
characteristics in these elements, besides Allah? The answer is no
one, except Him. The scientific community has just fathomed the rules
governing the elements and their specific characteristics, without
creating anything themselves. Why energy levels, arbitrarily denoted
as k, l, m, n, o, p by the
atomic scientists, exist around the nucleus, wherein specific numbers
of electrons can have a dynamic existence, is beyond the understanding
of the experts in the field. The same is true about the rule of octet
for the electronic arrangement.
Q-16:
Quran-70:4: The angels and the spirit ascend unto him in a day the
measure whereof is Fifty thousands years.
So,
which one is it ? Is the day of Allah equal to 1,000 earth years or
50,000 earth years ?
A-16:
In the realm of Alam-ul-Amr, Allah perfects the fundamental
physical, chemical and biological laws that uniformly apply throughout
the space-time continuum, with certain pertinent exceptions, which are
beyond the scope of the current discussion. However, the definition
of Youm, according to the Qur’an, is that period of time, which
is required for the completion of a particular task undertaken by the
forces at the command of the creator of the universe. A very logical
example is that of the evolution of the entire solar system through a
combination of spontaneous and regular changes. The completion of this
process took a Youm, an arbitrary unit of time designated for
each particular task. It is not measured exactly in 1,000 or 5,000
years of the earth’s time.
The
problem in understanding this concept is that like the Greek people,
the Arabian abacus was limited only to a thousand. They had no concept
that numbers could go beyond that limit. They used to identify the
number 1000 by the first letter of the Arabic lingo ‘alf”
because the independent units of ten and hundred fell in love with
each other to such an extent that they had no other way out except
coming together to form a thousand.
Allah
very well knew the numerical limitation of the Arabian Bedouin,
therefore, the counting never jumped beyond thousands. It simply means
that thousands mentioned in the Qur’an also mean innumerable. The
symbolic connotation of one or five thousand earthly years can run
into millions or billions of years. For instance, since the big bang,
the universe has taken 13.7 billions years to reach the current
status. This can be considered as one Youm or a combination
thereof. In fact, it’s just an arbitrary form of counting, without any
pinpoint accuracy. Anthropologists and even geologists use the same
kind of technique, when dating the age of a fossil or a rock. It
is never accurate and could be off by a margin of plus/minus 5 to 10
percent, which runs into millions of years on the geological scale.
However, His every Amr takes its own time and is continuing
throughout the cosmos at its own pace.
In
fact, the verse under discussion has nothing to do with the Greek
mythological fables of ascending and descending of angels or spirits,
in a day, extending up to fifty thousands earthly years. It is all
fictitious numbers game, which has nothing to do with the reality of
the universe or life on earth.
Creation of the Heaven and Earth
Q
–17: Which one was
created first ? As you will see in the verses below, Allah at one time
says that Earth was created first and another time he says that the
Heaven was created first.
Quran-2:29: It is He who hath created for you all things that are on
Earth; THEN He turned to the Heaven and made them into seven
firmaments (Skies).
Now,
does it match modern science ? Do you believe that, Earth was created
first, after that, God created Heaven ? Modern science tells us that ?
Or How come SEVEN firmaments (layers) ? Modern science tells us that,
actually there is no such thing Sky or any roof over us, it is only a
space with no known boundary at all. This verses simply reinforces the
ancient idea of ROOF over us which i s called SKY, is not it ? How
funny!
Quran-
79:27-30: Are you the harder to create, or is the heaven that He built
? He raised the height thereof and ordered it; and He has made dark
the night thereof, and He brought forth the morning thereof. And after
that, He spread (flattened) the earth
A-17:
Yousif Ali has misinterpreted this great verse. Its exposition
would be as follow.
‘The
laws governing life and death of nations have been established by
Allah, who has perfected the means of nourishment for the entire human
race, besides other creations on the living planet. You must also
establish a just society, based on an equitable and evenhanded
economic system, so that every individual can have the necessities of
life like housing, Medicare and education. Furthermore, if you look
around the universe enveloping the earth, you shall watch countless
luminous celestial bodies functioning harmoniously in the depth of
Space. Allah fashioned countless cosmic entities of various sizes,
masses and bulks. He accomplished all that on the basis of His
infinite knowledge. Allah, who has created the entire firmament and
maintains His authority in the cosmos by the introduction of critical
equilibrium, through balancing gravitational force and heat, has
bestowed up on you a similarly balanced economic system, for global
implementation.’
In the
above verse, if the word Summa signifies
‘after that,’ then your interpretation is justified; Allah first
created the Earth and then other clutter in the universe. However, in
this verse, the word Summa denotes
a demonstrative pronoun, indicating distance [near or far and wide].
The Qur’an has employed the same word with exactly the same
connotation in the verse 76:20.

‘And
wherever you shall look in that wonderful society [the system
established upon the Qur’anic constitution], you shall find all
kinds of Na’eema
[indicating a prosperous and flourishing way of living, where every
imaginable item of necessity is available in abundance and within the
reach of every person].
However, the Qur’an, in the verses 79:27, 28 and 30, has explained in
unambiguous terms that Allah first raised the firmament and then
hurled or propelled the Earth from its source.

‘O
Mohammad! Go and ask your opponents [who are trying to block the path
of constructive revolution], “Have you ever thought about your own
evolution. Do you think yourself to be stronger, numerous and so
difficult to create, as compared to the entire cosmos, with its
fundamental physical, chemical and biological codes, uniformly
applicable throughout the entire space-time continuum?”
Conversely, the creation of universe was not as simple a task, as we
might have thought, whereas perfecting humankind was, relatively, an
easier assignment for Allah in comparison to the stretching of the
firmament.
He
created the immense expanse of space and filled it up with gigantic
objects, like galaxies, clusters of galaxies and super clusters,
together with infinitesimally small quarks, including space-time
continuum all around and created a perfect abode.

‘He
raised all kinds of extraterrestrial entities high up in Space and
shaped each one of them meticulously, to function precisely to His
plan consistently, for producing the definite results.’

‘After
that, He set asunder and expanded the earth by hurling it through
space [originally elliptical like an egg], after it emerged out of a
primordial cluster of gas and dust.’
The
word ba’ada
indicates that the earth did not come into existence before every
thing else. On the contrary, it took shape out of an existing clump of
primordial mass or got detached from the gigantic bunch of matter
hurled out into space by the Sun.
In
fact, the Qur’an is not a treatise on Astronomy and does not provide a
chronological order of events that took over 13.7 billion years to
reach the current state. The facts about the nearest neighbors of the
Earth are mentioned to clarify certain contentious points with
pertinent examples.
Q-18:
Sunset and Sunrise
Koran teaches us that the Sun sets in a muddy spring:
Quran-18:86: Till, when he (the traveller Zul-qarnain) reached the
setting-place of the Sun, he found it going down into a muddy spring…
Quran- 18:90: Till, when he reached the rising-place of the Sun, he
found it rising on a people for whom We had appointed no shelter from
it.
Serious scientific errors here. Firstly, it is scientifically accepted
fact that, the Sun never go down in a muddy spring. Secondly, this
seems to presuppose a FLAT Earth, otherwise how can there be an
extreme point in the West or in the East ? A sunrise there would be
basically just the same as at any other place on this earth, at land
or sea. It would still look as if it is setting “far away”. It does
say, that he reached THE PLACE where the Sun sets and in his second
Journey the place where it rises
A-18:
The correct exposition of the verse 18:86 is given below. Please read
it carefully, as it might remove the ambiguity created by the
erroneous translation you have quoted.
‘So he
[the Zul-Qarnain] set out on a course, till he reached the setting
place of the sun and it appeared to him [Wajadaha] that it was setting
in black turbid sea and saw some people living near by.’
It is
just a metaphoric explanation of Sun setting in the vast expanse of an
ocean. Have you ever viewed the setting of the Sun in an ocean, while
standing on the beach? It appears to be going down in to the water.
Please keep in mind that at the time of Mohammad, the common people
had no concept of a spherical earth; it is just an allegory to bring
home the point that the Qur’an is making in that Sura. The
setting or rising of sun is not important at all, the message is
important that Allah is trying to get across to the people of all
times to come. The same is true with the sunrise. These events are
just mentioned by Allah to elucidate the principles being pronounced.
The screwed up translations of the text are wrecking havoc on the
exquisite allegories and metaphors being presented.
Q-19:
A resting place for Sun ?
Quran-36:38: And the sun runneth on unto a resting place for him. That
is the measuring of the Mighty, the Wise. Quran-36:39: And for the
moon We have appointed mansions till she return like an old shrivelled
palm leaf. Quran-36:40: It is not for Sun to overtake the moon, nor
doth the night outstrip the day. They float each in an orbit.
Allah is indeed a big scientist. Where is sun and where is moon
situated ? Can anybody tell me how they could collide/meet/overtake
each other ? Is the sun and moon are neighbors to each other ? I have
the answer for this error: Ancient allah saw (bare eye observations)
sun and moon travelling from east to west seemingly in the same Sky
area or same path, yet they do not collide and causing day and night
etc. Allah hardly could imagine that all these phenomena are simply
due to Earth’s rotation and NOT by Sun’s rotation. Sun is stationary
for Earth, because earth is stuck in the sun’s Gravity, like we are
stuck in earth’ gravity. Allah never say any where in the whole Quran
that, EARTH ROTATES. Perhaps Allah could not feel earth’s rotation.
A-19:
At the very outset, I would like to say that very frivolous matters
are being brought into the limelight, which tantamount to a mere
wasting of time. Your main problem is that, personally, you are an
Arabic illiterate and do not know what message the verses are
conveying for the uplift of the people. Depending on flawed
translations is your biggest handicap. Undoubtedly, the Sun is
revolving around a hypothetical center, along with all its planets and
their moons for the last 5 billion years. The Qur’an calls this status
as its temporary abode, meaning thereby a steady state for a
considerable length of time. However, in another estimated 4.5 to 5.0
billion years, it shall leave its current abode and eventually turn
into a black hole. That shall constitute the spontaneous change.
[36:38]
Every
event in the cosmos is taking place in accordance with Allah’s
directives, which reflects upon his might that He incorporates with a
blend of unbounded wisdom and infinite knowledge.
Regarding your comments, ‘Allah never say any where in the whole
Quran that, EARTH ROTATES. Perhaps Allah could not feel earth’s
rotation,’ presented herewith is the verse 79:30, that puts
forth the reality in focus:
The
Qur’an has specifically used the term dahaha
for the creation of the earth. It really signifies, hurling out a
blob of mass in space by a massive donor. The simplest example is that
of spin bowler, who throws the ball along a certain trajectory with an
axial spin. This word
dahaha means that the earth was tossed out into the outer space
by a colossal body [which the modern Astronomers identify to be the
Sun] along a specific path [inducing revolution], with rotation along
its axis. This reality, pertaining to earth’s creation, has been
explained in at length, vides the verse 31:10 and has been touched
upon in 26:15.
According to the cumulative cutting edge knowledge of Astronomy, there
are only two forces that are keeping harmony within the expanding
universe; one is heat and the other is gravity. The Qur’an mentions
both forces, just to show the reader that more than 150 billion
galaxies exist and function under a meticulously designed program by
the creator of the cosmos. The purpose is not to teach Astronomy to
the reader, but to give an idea that He, who commands the space-time
continuum, has presented a constitution to the whole humanity for
making the best of their lives in this world and in the hereafter.
Q
–20: A resting place for
sun WAS CONFIRMED BY HADITHS ?
Sahih Bukhari Hadiths: Abzur Ghifari (ra) narrated: one day Prophet
Mohammad (pbuh) asked me, “Abzar do you know after setting where does
Sun go?” I replied, I do not know, only Allah’s apostle can say
better. Then Prophet (SA) replied, “After setting, the sun remains
prostrated under Allah’s Aro ’sh and waits for allah’s command for
rising again in the East. Day will come when sun will not get
permission to rise again and Qeyamot will fall upon earth”.
Can
anybody tell me what is it ? It was the superstitious belief of
ancient people reflected in the Quran and Hadiths by Allah. A 10 year
old boy would not tell such fairy tale story today.
A-20:
The story about the setting sun that you have presented above is not
mentioned, anywhere, in the Qur’an. This Book presents the
constitution to be implemented on this planet for having the best of
both worlds. The Ahadith, Sunnah and Fiqah have nothing
to do with Islam, as these were personally written by the Iranian
antagonists of Allah, Mohammad the Arab and the Qur’an, some three
centuries after the demise of the last Messenger. This was the biggest
conspiracy hatched by them, against the Muslims, during the rule of
the Abbasid dynasty, when they had the caliphs under their thumb. The
confusion created by them has divided the Ummah into innumerable
sects, who are killing each other even in the 21st
century.
Q-21
Why Allah created Stars:
Quran gives us further scientific knowledge by telling us that the
stars were created by Allah as missiles to throw at the devils:
Quran-67:5: And We have (from of old) adorned the lowest heaven (sky)
with lamps, and We have made such (Lamps as) missiles to drive away
Satans… Quran-37:6-8: We have indeed decorated the lower heaven (sky)
with beauty (in) the stars, (for beauty) and for guard against all
obstinate rebellious Satans. So they should not strain their ears in
the direction of the Exalted Assembly but be cast away from every
side.
Thus, the stars are nothing but missiles to throw at devils so that
they may not eavesdrop on the heavenly council. Once again we find how
allah was high on his superstitious weirdness.
A-21:
The most accurate translation of above verse is as under:
‘We
have adorned the firmament with shining stars and have kept them
protected from all possible destructive forces. That is why; the
entire system is functioning so well, with complete order and
discipline. We have explained at length the purpose of Our creation
and exhibited the position of the stars, so that the real Satans
[soothsayers, witch doctors, astrologers and priests] should not be
able to rip off the simple and straightforward people by claiming, “We
do receive hidden information about your destiny from the bright
stars!” The lucid message of the Qur’an shall condemn their conjured
falsehood, speculative assumptions and guessing games to be rejected
by the society. The eternal commandments of the Qur’an shall expose
their ugly reality to the people and they shall face abominable hell
right in this world.’ [67:5, 15:17, 37:6-9 and 72:8]
Q-22
Sky/Heaven is nothing but A ROOF or Canopy over the Earth:
Quran-21: 32: And We have made the sky a roof withheld (from them).
Yet they turn away from its portents.
A-22:
In this verse, the word sky identifies the blue atmospheric envelope
[due to the cumulative effect of water vapors] around the earth that
extends up to 10 - 15 miles from the surface. The exposition of this
verse should be as follows:
‘Your
atmosphere or rather earth’s atmosphere very well protects the ground
from the falling meteors and other cosmic debris, including deadly
radiations. This is, therefore, evident that every object in this
universe bows down to the sovereignty of Allah and follows the
prescribed divine rules. Despite this clear-cut evidence, some
stubborn, ignorant and dim-witted people still keep on rejecting the
proof of His immaculate creation.’
Q-23:
Quran-31:10: He hath created the heavens (Skies) without supports
(pillars) that ye can see, and hath cast into the earth firm
Mountains/Hills, so that it quake not with you; and He hath
dispersed…..
A-23:
This query has already been taken care off under the A-17.
Q-24
Quran-21: 32: And We have made the sky ( heavens ) as roof (canopy)
well guarded
A-24:
This query has already been taken care off under the A -17. Q-25:
Quran-2: 22: Who has made the earth your couch, And the heavens (Sky)
your canop Modern science tells us- whole thing around the earth is
space and there is no boundary even we go Billions of Trillions of
miles in all direction. Questions are: When there is no sky above us
then how in the world, question of pillars comes ? Do we really have a
roof above us ? Is there a canopy (Shamiaa’na) above the earth ? In
most Bengali translated Quran all Maulanas writes: Allah akashke
samiaana bannei-ese . Is there anything called above or bellow in true
sense ? Are mountains there to prevent earth from shaking ? Give me a
break !
A-25:
The correct exposition of the verses referred above is as follows:
‘You
shall find protection from hazards and vicissitudes of life only
within the universal system of Rububiyat [nourishing system of
the Qur’an], according to which Allah has turned the Earth into a safe
abode [like a mother’s womb] for you and scattered innumerable stars
and planets in space, which stay in their precise orbits through the
mutually acting potent gravitational force, acting at right angle
throughout the universe. Allah has also made arrangements for the
clouds to pour down life inducing rain, in order to provide you with
the means of nourishment. Evidently, this grandiose sustenance setup
has been granted to you free of charge; however, Allah remains the
sole Owner and Master of these abundant resources, and permits you to
utilize them, but never to block their use for others. Therefore, be
vigilant, and do not let an individual or a group of people to reserve
them for their personal utilization or their progeney. If that ever
happens, it would tantamount to shrik [revolt], or assigning
equals to Allah.’
In the
above verse, the term “Shamia’na” signifies the earth’s
atmosphere, which is wrapped around it like a cover and looks like a
blue canopy on a clear day. The survival of life on this planet
depends upon this protective environment that not only supports the
floating clouds, but also acts as a powerful filter to keep out the
deadly cosmic radiations from reaching the surface. Geologically
speaking, the worldwide mountain ranges do stabilize the earth crust
and were formed over billions of years, as a result of the ongoing
tectonic activity or interaction.
The
terms and expressions used in the Qur’an were in consonance with the
mental capacity of the people and their understanding of their
surroundings at that time. That is why; the metaphors and allegories
used in the last revelation allude to the commonplace objects and
events of that era. Please keep that in mind and also be assured that
the Book of Allah does not have any clash with the modern cumulative
scientific knowledge, including latest discoveries and the technical
advancement.
A word
of caution and advice! Almost all expositions of the Qur’an are
screwed up. The alleged exponents of the Qur’an, the world over, are
copying, what was written by Iranian Abn-e-Kater in the 3rd
century Higra, who tried his level best to distort the straightforward
message of the last revelation. He quite successfully created
confusion and rift between the Muslim Ummah, which culminated in the
formation of sects.
Q-26: Once again Allah
considered sky as roof over the earth which will break/shattered
during dooms day
Quran-78:19 And the heavens (sky) Shall be broken (opened) as if there
were doors opens
A-26:
The translation of the verses you have presented above does not make
any sense. In fact, the concept of Doomsday, in terms of the total
annihilation of the firmament is non-Qur’anic and has been borrowed by
the Islamic priesthood from the Jewish and Christian fabricators.
With
reference to the context, it actually means that with the
implementation of the Qur'anic constitution, the powerful empires and
their tyrannical monarchs, along with the domineering local leaders,
who are opposing this constructive program, shall be wiped out from
the face of the earth. Their secretive dealings and conspiracies to
suppress their subjects shall be blown open for every one to see their
ugly faces and the evil deeds that they had been carrying out against
the commoners. It shall be an exposé of the kind that the world had
never seen before.
Thus,
in the above verse, the heaven [sky] is an allegorical representation
of the despotic rulers or corrupt political leaders running
governments through fraudulent and underhand dealings. The literal
translation of this verse that the heaven shall bust open like a blown
up building or its pieces shall fly over like the doors and windows of
a blasted house is not doing justice to the Qur’anic quotation, with
particular reference to the context. Scientifically speaking, the
cosmos is not going to experience such a cataclysmic turn of events in
billions of years. What are the cutting edge Astronomical projections
about this event are beyond the scope of the discussion at hand.
However, they support the Qur’anic viewpoint that the space-time
continuum is a reality and the cosmic system within its grip is going
to stay like that forever. There are certain unfounded computer
generated patterns or graphics about the end of the universe, but they
are too far fetched at this point in time. Please always disregard the
unintelligent expositions of the verses of the last revelation.
Q-27:
Quran-82:01: When the Sky is cleft asunder
A-27:
Detailed explanation pertaining to this subject has been provided
under the A-14. There is no need to repeat it here.
Q-28:
Quran-69:16: And the sky will be Rent asunder, for it will That day be
flimsy(soft
A-28: Please look up
A-14 for the answer.
Q-29:
Quran-81: 2: When the stars fall, losing their lustre.
A-29:
Here again, the Qur’an talks about the stars not in the sky, but on
the ground [in the form of petty governments or minor leaders, who
were opposing the implementation of the divine social program in their
areas of influence or were the supporters of the foreign big foreign
powers like Iranian Monarchy and Roman Empire]. They shall face
crushing defeat and their power shall be destroyed forever.
Note:
Sun,
the symbol of utmost power, was inscribed on the flag of the Iranian
Empire, whereas, the Roman ensign was decorated with the moon. The
stars represented other small states, whose survival was dependent
upon their close ties with those two dominant powers, sprawled on the
geo-political map, in that part of the world. They had no other
choice, but to join either of the two camps, as was the case in the
cold war era, extending from the decades of 60’s to 90’s.
Q-30: Yousuf Ali
comments in his Tafsir: beautiful blue sky overhead (which we take for
granted in sunshine ) will be shattered to pieces. Modern science
tells us that there is no such thing as roof/sky or any canopy over
the earth, rather all around earth is a limitless space. Only Allah
knows what will break/shattered or will get soft/flimsy or how doors
will open, there is no wall, where from doors will come? In some Ayats
Allah threatened kafirs by saying: “I (Allah) will throw broken pieces
of sky over your head.”
A-30:
Yousif Ali’s exposition or his Tafseer is not the last word on the
subject. Almost all alleged Muslim scholars followed the translation
of Abne Kater, the Iranian, which appeared three centuries after the
death of the last Messenger. His work suffers from convoluted
connotations of the Qur’an and is not worth the paper it is written
on. Every Muslim must understand the last Book of Allah, utilizing the
procedure provided in there. This way all ambiguities, created by
these obtuse exponents of the Book, shall vanish forever.
Q-31:
Sun and moon rotates:
Quran-31: 29: Seest thou not that Allah merges Night into Day and He
merges Day into Night; That He has subjected the sun and moon (to His
law), each running its course for a term (time) appointed
A-31:
‘The most appropriate translation of the verse quoted above should run
like this:
‘The
people, who are opposing the establishment of this peaceful system of
government, have they ever thought about the immense importance of
Time [the paradoxical unidirectional fourth dimension of the cosmos].
He created the Day [an active phase of life, like cascading and
surging mountain rivulet] and the Night [a period of darkness] for
rest and recuperation, to meet the challenges of the next day, head
on. * He made the sun and the moon subservient to you. Each
revolves around its prescribed orbit for a given time.His Law of
Requital is fully applicable and He has full cognizance of all your
activities at all times, which you carry on overtly or covertly.
*Note:
[However, the frontal memory lobes of every human brain keep track of
all good and bad activities going on and that record shall provide the
composite basis of His judgment.]
Q-32:
Quran-21: 33: It is He who created The Night and Day, And the Sun and
Moon; each of them Swim (float) along in its own course
A-32:
The Qur’an has a unique and inimitable recurring style to instill the
facts and realities, in the memory banks of the intelligent life forms
on this planet and beyond. In the verse 21:33, the same basic thought
has been presented in a slightly variant manner.
‘Mohammad make an open declaration to your adversaries, who are trying
to block the path of this peaceful revolution, which comes from the
One, who created the day and night on this planet through the axial
rotation of the sun and the moon! Like these bodies all other visible
stars are actively swimming in the space-time continuum [like strong
swimmers] along their specific trajectories in order to produce the
projected results.’
Q-33:
Ayats mentioned above could be found over and over again and again
almost in every pages of Quran. Because, Allah standing in the open
Arab desert saw very well that, every morning SUN is rising from the
east and gradually (appointed time or fixed time) setting to the west,
and as a result, day and night follows. Allah truly mentioned this
wrong knowledge (sun moving) of pre-historic people. Every time Allah
mentioned sun & moon, He mentioned day & night, as if it is due to
sun’s movement day and night follows. But surprisingly, all the
hypocrite Mullahs giving false credit to Allah by saying: look Quran
told about sun’s movement 1400 years ago which modern science only
found out now. In real world, sun takes 225 millions of years to make
just one complete circle through the solar Universe. And obviously
this movement of sun has nothing to do with DAY & NIGHT of the earth.
Actually, Sun is stationary for the earth in real sense, because earth
is stuck to the giant gravitation force of sun and earth also move
along with sun wherever it goes, just the way we are stuck to earth’s
gravitation force and do not feel earth’s movement at all.
Why
then, Allah was telling sun’s movement again and again. I have already
mentioned above, why Allah was hysteric about sun’s movements. Now
dishonest Mullahs are claiming science here. I wonder, why Allah has
to mentioned about sun’s 225 millions year journey (which is even
unbelievable to mankind) to tell about day and night ? What relation
sun’s movement has with the day and night ?
A-33: Your thinking is
totally off the mark, as Allah was not teaching Astronomy to the
simple people of the desert, who were very well conversant with the
daily occurrence of day and night. In addition, there is nothing wrong
with this comment of the Qur’an that day and night follows each other
and it happens due to the specific revolutions of sun, moon and earth
along their specific trajectories. The verse 21:33 is a beautiful
metaphorical representation of the movement of the most observable
members of the solar system. They are really floating along their
fixed paths and cannot deviate from it.
This
example of Allah’s obvious celestial arrangement gives impetus to
various contextual situations, wherever this line of reasoning has
been used. The problem is that the translations of the Qur’an right
from Ibne-Kathir are flawed and create confusion in the mind of the
reader, instead of providing the true explanation.
A
pertinent example from history may clear up this ambiguity. Galileo,
the famous Astronomer of 17th century spent a good part of
his advanced life in prison, on the order of the church, because he
said, that earth revolves around the stationary sun. The church
believed the other way round; this clash made his life miserable. The
church accepted their mistake after 350 years and apologized to
Galileo posthumously.
To sum
up this line of argument, it must be understood that sun also moves
along its orbit with the whole planetary system, but the day and night
are only formed with the specific rotations of earth and moon. It is
also true about other planets, but the durations of axial rotations
are different. Jupiter, the biggest planet of the solar system makes a
complete rotates in 9 hours and 55 minutes. Every planet has its cycle
of day and night and it occurs due to the rotation of the planet with
respect to the sun and its moon or moons.
The
movement of sun is also of crucial importance. If it had a jerky
movement, like some of the massive stars, earth could never have been
inhabitable. Or if it had been a Pulsar, the same could happen; we
could be plunging from plus 200 degrees C to minus 200 degrees C
intermittently and for billions of years. The smooth movement of the
sun is very important for the formation of days and nights. On the
other hand, if the earth had an elliptical orbit like Haley’s Comet,
then the inhabitants of earth could see sunlight for only 5 to 10
years out of its 77 year cycle.
The
verses of the Qur’an try to explain the realities of life by giving
pertinent examples from the universe around us. Get that point with an
open mind.
Q-34:
Earth is spread out like carpet (flat)
Quran-15:19: And the earth We have spread out (like a carpet); set
thereon Mountains firm and immovable;
Quran-78: 6-7: Have We not made the earth as a wide expanse, And the
mountains as pegs (anchor) ?
Allah was sure that earth is flat like a carpet and mountains are
there to anchor the earth so that earth does not shake with us. Allah
is really merciful scientist
A-34:
Please remember one point that the addressees of the Qur’an were very
simple minded people and did not have any knowledge of the cosmos.
Allah in a beautiful metaphorical manner is trying to tell the
receivers of the Qur’an about the visible reality spread all around
them. They used carpets in their homes or tents for sitting down and
Allah used it as a simile for spreading the earth under their feet.
What is wrong with that? Those people must have understood it without
any problem. It also means that the earth is spread like a gigantic
rug and the mountains keep it in place. At that time they had no
concept that the earth was round like a globe. This concept developed
much later. In fact, the mountain ranges do regulate the tectonic
activity, as the mountains originated due to the plate collision. A
very pertinent example is that of Himalayas and the Karakoram
ranges. These originated with the collision of the Indian plate with
the Gondwanaland some seventy million years ago, when the Tethys Sea
in between them folded up into the mountain ranges. Undoubtedly, Allah
is the greatest creator, who nourishes the gradual and spontaneous
changes everywhere in the cosmos.
Q-35:
Man are created from Clotted blood ?
Quran-23:14: Then fashioned We the drop (semen) a CLOT OF CONGEALED
BLOOD then fashioned We the Clot a little lump (foetus), fashioned We
the little lump into bones, then clothed the bones with flesh, and
then produced it another creation. So blessed be Allah, the Best of
Creators. ( Bengali translated Quran said: “Zamaa’t Raokto theeke
Manoosh banieesi” And this Ayat has been repeated again and again
throughout the Quran ) Quran-75:38: Then he becomes a CLOT; then
(Allah) shaped and fashioned…
Quran-96:2: Created man, out of a mere clot of congealed blood
There are serious scientific problems here:
Blood clot can not grow into anything. This idea also came from the
Greek. Aristotle erroneously believed that, humans are originated from
the action of male semen upon female menstrual blood which is
absolutely an incorrect assumption. Quran’s assertion on Clot (alaqa)
is completely wrong about human development, since there is absolutely
no stage during which the embryo consists of a clot. The only
situation in which an embryo might appear like a clot is during a
miscarriage, in which case the clotted blood which is seen to emerge
(much of which comes from mother) is solidified and by definition no
longer alive. Therefore, if ever an embryo appeared to look like a
clot it would never develop any further into a human; it would be a
dead mass of bloody miscarrying flesh. Since Prophet Muhammad (pbuh)
had some thirteen wives it is entirely possible that he would be very
familiar with miscarriages.
Modern science tells us that, the formation of human embryo is a
seamless continuation from conception to birth, hence there is no
hard- and- fast boundaries of stages as Quran described. Quran
described 4 stages which matches exactly with Galenic description of
development of human embryo (which was proved wrong by modern
science).
Creation of bones and clothing of bones with flesh: According to
modern embryologists including Prof. Moore, the tissue from which bone
originates, known as mesoderm, is the same tissue as that from which
muscle (flesh) develops. Thus bone and muscles begin to develop
simultaneously, rather than sequentially (as the Quran telling us).
Moreover, most of the muscle tissue that we human have is laid down
before birth, but bones continue to develop and calcify (strengthen
with calcium) right into one’s teenage years. So it would be more
accurate if the Quran had said that muscles started to develop at the
same time as bones, but completed their development earlier. The idea
that bones are clothed with flesh is not only scientifically
completely wrong/false, but was directly copied from the ancient Greek
doctor Galen’s hypothesis.
Also, the idea of saying : “made into bones and clothed the bones with
muscle” came from the technique of making animal statue (Moorthy) out
of rod and cement or mud. People usually make the skeleton (out of rod
or stick) first and, then cover it up with cement or mud. This is
scarcely a scientific description of embryonic development. It is
rather a description of a lay man.
The
Quran has used the
Which one is correct ?
A-35:
The detailed anatomical knowledge that you are referring to was beyond
the understanding of the simple minded Arabs, at the time of the
Qur’an’s revelation. The Iranian Imams, [both Shi’ah and
Sunni] the real enemies of the Qur’an were unable to change the
original text, but they definitely corrupted the meanings of the
Qur’anic words, terms and expressions. The most convincing evidence of
this conspiracy is presented by the translation of the verse 23:14,
regarding with you have raised an objection.
The
right interpretation of the above verse would be presented after
discussing the key word ‘Alaq’ in detail.
Expressing ‘Alaq’ as a blood clot only is doing extreme
injustice to the Arabic literature, its lexicon, and the basic roots
of the word Alaq. Understanding this word is of utmost
importance for grasping the crux of this verse.
It also
carries the following connotations:
·
It signifies an object
hung up or suspended. Additionally, it also means a strong bond
created by a powerful sticking agent, which makes a couple of things
stick together, like Crazy Glue.
·
This word also denotes
a very precious entity, having a very high estimation.
·
A blood sucking red or
black leech is also called ‘Alaq’, encompassing
other worms categorized under that phylum.
The
term ‘Moalaqa’ a derivative of ‘Alaq,’ is used for a
woman, whose husband goes missing, or leaves her in a state of marital
uncertainty. She can’t be categorized either as a married or free
female and her life stays suspended in such a situation.
In view
of the above definition of the crucial word ‘Alaq’, the
exposition of the above verse should be as under:
‘In the
first phase of evolution, We created life forms by mixing together
inorganic and organic ingredients. Then, in the second phase, We
created humans through the process of reproduction.’
Brief
details of this process are as under:
‘The
procreation begins, when a single male sperm, [out of about ten
millions] fuses with a solitary ovum. After that incident a fetus
begins to develop, which the Qur’an identifies as the elementary stage
known as Alaq. This microscopic microbe adheres to the wall of
the uterus and stays kind of suspended. This state of the budding new
life is very precious, from the Qur’anic perspective, as it contains
the complete Gnome together with the requisite materials to build a
new live form. At this point, the Alaq just acts like a leech
and lives off the blood supply of an expecting mother and is devoid of
gender identification.
Surviving the initial developmental hazards, it them begins to grow
and then turns into a lump, still sticking to the wall of the uterus.
From here onwards, the bone structure develops, which are embedded in
to the retaining muscles and tissues.
Among
the Mammals this is the mode of procreation and all animals along with
the human beings pass through the same process. However, they attain
different forms dictated by their respective genetic makeup contained
in the embryo.
The
humans appeared latest in the series of life forms, some 120,000 to
200,000 years ago and are totally different from all other animals in
various distinct faculties, like speaking, reading and writing. No
other species possesses those capabilities.
Think
about this reality that the Qur’an declared the process of
pro-creation 1400 years ago and it is totally compatible with the most
modern research in this field. Your problem is that you are totally
ignorant with respect to the message of the Qur’an and your objections
are just based on unsubstantiated information. To find fault with the
last Book of Allah, you must first understand the language, the text
and the syntax. Your ignorance is the cause of your confused mental
state. You must remember that for raising objections about any matter,
you must possess thorough knowledge about it. Better wake up, and
educate yourself!
Your
comments about Mohammad’s harem of some thirteen wives is baseless, as
this information comes from fabricated Ahadith, a well thought
out and planned Iranian conspiracy against Mohammad the Arab. His
antagonists wrote these stories personally in his name, some 300 years
after his death. There is not even an iota of reality in there.
On the
contrary, as per Sura Al-Tahreem, he had only two wives
before his prestigious appointment to the position of Allah’s last
Messenger. Moreover, Allah declared in unambiguous terms, “Since
receiving revelations, you are forbidden to marry any other woman,
even though you do like someone special due to her exceptional charm
and beauty. In addition, you are also ordained, not to divorce any one
of your current wives or replace them with others. You better stay put
in that regard.”
In the
presence of such a command from Allah to his Messenger, could the
latter dare to defy it and build a harem, as the Iranian conspirators
are blaming him for, after a wide lapse of time, spread over 300
years. This must always be kept in mind that no messenger of Allah
could ever go against his nourisher, especially in the presence of the
code of conduct given to him.
All
Ahadith referring to his harem are just a slur on his impeccable
character and his stalwart personality; they are nothing more than a
pack of lies synthesized by both the Shi’ah and Sunni
Imams.
Q-36: Quran-2:256: There is no Compulsion in religion….
OR
Quran-9:29: Fight those who do not profess the true faith (Islam) till
they pay the polltax (jiziya) with the hand of humility. Quran-9:5:
Then, when the sacred months have passed, slay the idolators wherever
ye find them and take them captive, and besiege them and prepare for
them each ambush…. Quran-47:4: When you meet the unbelievers in the
Jihad strike off their heads….
A-36:
Allah, the nourisher and nurturer of the entire universe and beyond,
has given the people open choice, either to accept or reject the
Qur’anic code of life. He identified both the right and the wrong
paths to them in his last Book, along with the option to select any
one out of their free will, without any coercion.
Your
objection regarding the verse 9:29, why non-Muslims, living in the
areas under the control of an Islamic government, have to pay poll
tax? [This term is inadequate to represent Jiziya. In fact, it’s a
kind of protection tax.]
There
is nothing wrong with it. The government has to make special
arrangements for the protection of minorities living within its
boundaries and that costs money; so they should pay a little extra to
cover additional expenses incurred. This is very easy to understand by
looking at the Muslims living in foreign countries, especially in EU
or North America, who have to pay all taxes that are levied by the
respective governments. No Muslim has raised any objection or shown
reluctance to pay the taxes. They can object, why their hard earned
money is being spent on the programs they do no benefit them in any
way.
However, the non-Muslims living under the Islamic government enjoyed
all rights and privileges like other citizens. There was no
discrimination against them, because the Government established under
the Qur’anic constitution insists up on the people not to live for
themselves only, but also for the others. It is very simple to
understand that the non-Muslims who are living within the boundaries
of the Islamic system enjoy full human rights, safety and security so
they have to pay some thing extra to enjoy that status.
All
civilized governments of the world do not tolerate sedition. In some
sovereign countries, the punishment for rebellion is death. The people
working against the interest of the state are dealt with a heavy hand.
That was also the case in the time of Mohammad. The Qur’an lays down
basic rules for such situations within the state and with respect to
the outside aggression. Please keep in mind that the nascent Islamic
state established in Medina was extremely fragile and it was the duty
of the establishment to save it both from internal as well external
threats.
The
guideline provided by the Qur’an in the above mentioned situations are
as under:
1.
Go and fight against the insurgents or the foreign forces, till
they are defeated and destroyed.
2.
Arrest them.
3.
Lay siege around their communities.
4.
If they give up rebellious attitude and want to participate in
the establishment of a peaceful society voluntarily, then do not
pursue them any longer. On the contrary, protect them and provide them
with the necessary means of nourishment in order to turn them into
productive citizens.
Your
explanation of the verse 47:4, ‘whenever or wherever you confront the
unbelievers in the situation of Jihad, chop their heads off is simply
baseless and ridiculous.
If any
aggressive force were attacking you from within or without, what would
be your reaction? Would you welcome them and offer your heads to be
chopped off? The Qur’an provides the entire humanity the right of
self-defense and retaliation against the aggressors.
NOTE:
The
Bush doctrine of pre-emptive attacks on nations, suspected of possible
aggression against his nation, not only violate the UNO charter, but
is also against the tenets of the Qur’an.
The
correct exposition of the above verse is as follows:
‘If the
opponents of this peaceful program attack you, then defend yourself
with a counter attack, with full force. Chop off their heads till you
prevail. In case of capturing them, either cut them loose, as a
gesture of goodwill, or receive ransom for their freedom, with the
proviso that they lay down their arms. Remember; humans are born free
from the wombs of their mothers. This is precisely Allah’s command for
the people, who wage war against others without any just cause.’
Here, I
would like to know, what is wrong with the command of the Qur’an?
Where is the permission for the Muslim army to use excessive force or
convert the non-Muslims forcibly to Islam?
Q-37:
Quran-2:191: And slay (kill) them wherever ye catch them, and turn
them out from where they have turned you out such is the reward of
those who suppress faith.
A-37:
Your translation presents the fact that the opponents of this peaceful
revolution expelled the Muslims from their homes, in the first place.
Under the circumstances, the Qur’an provides the Muslims the right to
defend themselves against aggression and pay them back in the same
coins. What is so awfully wrong with this directive of Allah? The
right of self-defense is recognized the world over and there is no
provision under any law not to punish your adversary.
Q-38:
Quran-8: 65: O Apostle ! rouse the believers to the fight
….unbelievers.
A-38:
In the above verse, the Qur’an directs the Muslims to have proper
training for all types of warfare and steadfastly work for the
establishment of a peaceful society. If they follow that commandment,
then one hundred of them would be powerful enough to defeat a thousand
of their opponents. This directive is completely logical and ensures
peace and prosperity of a powerful nation.
Q-39: Very often apologetics claim that, Islam is a religion of peace
and there is no compulsion Yet, punishment of an apostate in Islam is,
of course, death penalty.
A-39:
Of course, the Qur’an insists upon the establishment of a peaceful and
prosperous society, coupled with adequate security. But peace and
tranquility can never be achieved through offering prayers or counting
beads. It only comes through the maintenance of proper deterrence and
keeping a fighting force superior in numbers and weapons, as compared
to the potential adversaries.
Being
an Arab and a Muslim, it is disgraceful on your part to be completely
ignorant pertaining to the basic principles encoded in the Qur’an.
Show me, where the Qur’an sentences an apostate to death! The Muslims
clergy coined this term on their own, without presenting a single
verse in its support.
If you
so desire, you can rescind Islam with your own free will. Allah does
not require your kind of Muslims, who are worst than even four legged
animals. It shall give me pleasure, if you become a Hindu, a
Zoroastrian or a Christian. Go where you can find peace of mind,
without using your Allah given sense of reasoning and wisdom.
Q-40:
In very many Ayats Allah claimed that, He has given this Quran in the
easy and clear language so that, it will not be difficult to
understand by the ordinary Arabs.
Quran-44:58: Verily, We have made This Quran easy in the tongue, in
order that they may give heed.
A-40:
Yes that is precisely true! Undoubtedly, the language of the last
revelation is very plain, simple and clear to understand for them, who
can comprehend it. But the problem is that 90% of the Muslims just
read the text for the sake of Swab [Allah’s reward] and not
understanding, what is being said. The fact remains that almost 80% of
the Muslims are Arabic illiterate, then how can they have any
comprehension, about the subject matter under discussion and the
message being conveyed by various Suras or even ayas?
Ironically, Muslims are the only people on the face of the earth, a
vast majority of which just reads the Book revealed to them, without
understanding a single word. On top of that, they arrange
international Qur’an recital competitions, giving the idea to the
simple hearted Arabic illiterate Muslims, this is best way to pay
homage to the Book given to them for guidance in every sphere of life.
This attitude is not only ridiculous, but shows the demented
collective thinking and attitude of a nation that feels pride for
being recipient of the last revelation of Allah. Undoubtedly, they are
even worst than the four-legged animals, which are considered dumb by
most of the human beings.
Q-41:
No matter which translated Quran we read, the Quranic materials remain
same to us and every sentence is self explanatory and it does not take
a rocket scientist to comprehend what is the message Allah wanted to
transmit for Arabs. Yet, bigot Mullahs will always blame translators
for Quranic contradictions/errors/inconsistencies etc. and will try to
find lame excuse to cover up Allahs ignorance.
A-41:
I agree with you because in all translations currently available, you
will find countless contradictions and inconsistencies. However, try
my book; in there you will find exposition of almost five hundred
verses of the Qur’an. I would like to have your comments, if you ever
go through it. It is now available at all bookstores of Chapters in
North America and can also be obtained from Amazon.com. Orders can be
placed online.
Comments:
Holy
Qur’an is full of inaccuracies, contradictions, inconsistencies,
redundancies, no chronology or chapters, Grammatical errors etc. One
can find hundreds of contradictions/errors/inconsistencies in Holy
Quran and above mentioned Ayats are just selected samples from the
Quran. But still it is a miracle to those who are blind-folded bigot.
Answer:
The
above observations about the Qur’an are not based upon on any concrete
evidence. You are talking about grammatical and other mistakes in the
last book of Allah; you are dead wrong. Japanese researchers have
recently refuted your imperceptive claim, as a result of their
extensive study. According to them, the entire text is free of even a
single linguistic error. You being an Arabic illiterate, have no right
to give such sweeping statements about the Qur’an. You should be
ashamed of your irresponsible behavior.
“
The mind of a bigot is like the pupil of the eye; the more light you
pour upon it, the more it will contract.”- Oliver Wendell Holmes
I fully
agree with the quotation of Mr. Wendell Homes.
Finally, if any one of you still experiences any confusion or
difficulty in understanding any verses of the Qur’an, please feel free
to get in touch with us. We shall be delighted to do our utmost to
clear it up, with the best of our ability, as the fact remains that
people do face problems pertaining to the comprehension of the verses,
due to the erratic translations of the purported exponents of the last
revelation.
Akhtar
Sherazi
Safdar
Agha
Editor
and Co-Writer |